This probably doesn't suck as an idea.

One of the shortcomings of as-sets in RPSL was that there was no forward security when including as-sets. In other words, anyone could include any other AS or as-set in their own as-set. This allowed a good degree of flexibility, but could also create hilariously obnoxious results, for example the time that someone included AS-SET-INEX-RS in their own as-set, then did an AS7007 job towards INEX's route servers. Much code was written in anger that day, oh yes, there was.

Anyway, if there were moves to think about whether it would be possible to include some form of inclusion authorisation mechanism, that would solve some actual problems.

Nick

_______________________________________________
GROW mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/grow

Reply via email to