"Dr. Arne Babenhauserheide" <[email protected]> writes:

> ' is explicitly defined as token, but so are other syntactic sugars
> (` , @, .) and those are accepted in identifiers.
>
> So I think compatibility should go the other way round and have an opt
> in for splitting up identifiers on '.

This goes deeper: racket disallows any token in identifiers, but chicken
accepts ` (but turns it into |a`b| on writing) while splitting on ' and
failing on , (replaced by unquote).

And Guile accepts all tokens as part of identifiers that are not
delimiters (but now started to warn on ').

The most robust way I found to try it out is '(a`b a'b a,b a,@b):

Guile: (a`b a'b a,b a,@b)
Racket/Chez: (a `b a 'b a ,b a ,@b)
Chicken: (|a`b| a (quote b) a (unquote b) a (unquote-splicing b))
sbcl: (A `B A 'B) ; fails on , and ,@
emacs: (a `b a 'b a (\, b) a (\,@ b))
kawa: (a (quasiquote b) a (quote b) a (unquote b) a (unquote-splicing b))
mit: (a (quasiquote b) a (quote b) a (unquote b) a (unquote-splicing b))

(note the white space signifying that identifiers were split)

Best wishes,
Arne
-- 
Unpolitisch sein
heißt politisch sein,
ohne es zu merken.
https://www.draketo.de

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to