Hi Anthony:

Thanks for the response.  See below.

 -------------- Original message ----------------------
From: Anthony Jackson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> > Hi all:
> > 
> > I posted the following a couple years ago-- it may be pertinent to
> > this thread. ----------------- I think I have a proposal to come up
> > with a legitimate distribution for G:IQ scores.  Tell me what you
> > think:
> > 
> > 1. We go to the store and buy an IQ test.  It should have a scale at
> > the end that shows correct # of answers as compared to RL IQ.
> 
> This presupposes that GURPS IQ measures the same things as are measured 
> by an IQ test. IQ tests largely measure the skill 'IQ tests' (mental 
> hobby skill)
> > 
Yes, and I propose this is a MA skill, and superimpose it on the distribution.  
It correlates back to G:IQ along a 3d6 distribution, and the question is, how 
does that distribution relate at points along the RL IQ test distribution?

> > 2. We agree that G:IQ is a function of problem-solving ability
> > utilizing the 3d6 distribution.
> 
> As different IQ tests have different percentages correct for a given IQ 
> score, this seems very dubious. Not all questions on an IQ test are 
> equally hard.

Perhaps so, but as the table suggests, they don't discriminate between "got 
problem 45 right and problem 40 wrong, so IQ is higher than if vice-versa".    
You should probably tell the test-makers!

Moreover, if tested properly, the IQ test scale is formulated based on actual 
scores on what is hopefully a random sample of the population (and derived 
statistically).  The fact that the distributions worked out somewhat elegantly 
in this particular case *could* be coincidence... but this is a point of 
reference, and I rather like it, so I thought I'd offer it up again.

In fact, if you think about it, and just mathematically look at 3d6 and compare 
it with the normal distribution, you can probably derive some kind of 
conversion formula between GURPS and population.  Any of you math types have 
any thoughts on that?
I might take a closer look at that...

-vk

_______________________________________________
GurpsNet-L mailing list <[email protected]>
http://mail.sjgames.com/mailman/listinfo/gurpsnet-l

Reply via email to