Hi Donna,
"Buy-out?
Lawsuits? That's new on me"
Yep, Freedom scientific was bought out several years ago by an east
indian venture capitalist firm. It's there berried on the web site
somewhere if you have a while to go poking around for it. All the
people are still more or less the same, but the backing is no longer
American.
4 or 5 years ago now, fs sued Sarotech the makers of what was then
called the freedom box. The freedom box was a sort of stand alone
opperating system to turn your computer into a totally blind friendly
machine, and it had it's own network behind it and so on. Because it
was called the freedom box, fs contended that it infringed their
trademark rights to the corprate name Freedom Scientific. I don't
know how they won that suit, but the companies settled out of court,
and Sarotech renamed the freedom box to something that no one
remembers any more.
Currently, fs is suing gw over a feature of window-eyes called place
markers, which works completely differently from the jaws version, but
is called the same thing. It will be interesting to see how that
comes out, but I suspect the biggest losers here will be window-eyes
customers, as the cost in time and money to fight the thing will
seriously impact the next releace of window-eyes. The big feature for
the next releace is going to be 64 bit support, and so the suite will
probably delay the releace at least a little bit to give fs an edge so
they can say they did it first.
"I confess, though I agree with you about FS I feel
a twinge of loyalty, just b/c they were there back in the 80s and 90s,
when no one else was doing that much to make anything accessible."
Lol, I have to disagree with you again. The first screen reader for
windows was developped by syntha-voice computing in I think 1987, and
it's in the smithsonian as the first ever windows screen reader. It
was developped through several incarnations right up to 2002 when the
founder of the company died and the product was shelved. Then a few
years ago there were nogotiations in the pipe to bring window bridge
back, rebuild it for 32 bit windows platforms and releace it as open
source software, but it fell through I think. WB was at least as
powerful as jaws, but even in it's early incarnations, the
customization was a lot more accessible to the user than jaws scripts,
or even window-eyes com automation. You didn't have to write code or
know programming consepts, just be prepaired to sit for hours checking
boxes and filling in edit boxes. I'm a proud owner of window bridge
and though I don't use it any more because the software it was built
for is long out of date, I still have very fond memories of it.
" And I will say, that at this point, I think the Pacmate is a more
sophisticated device than the BS--which of course also means it can
be a
lot less user-friendly."
I can't argue with you there. I haven't used a pack mate, and despite
my overall good impression of the braille sense, I try to steer my
clients away from proprietary note taking solutions if possible. In
defense of the bs, I have to say that it has a whole lot more hardware
in it than any of the other devices on the market right now. That's
why I recomend it. My client gets more bang for their hardware buck.
Of course, most of them don't need tls support, and wouldn't know or
care about email security. Most don't want to use it as a braille
terminal. They want something to read braille books with, type up
documents on, and keep notes. If I have a client who really uses all
the features of a note taker like calendar, contact manager, and so
on, I try to steer them to a mobile phone solution like the code
factory stuff because of the vastly reduced cost of upgrading.
Also in defense of the braille sense, I should say it hasn't been
developed nearly as long as the pack mate. Firmware updates have been
pretty regular, and I haven't felt that my suggestions for features
have gone unrecognized. So, it's possible that in the long term you
have a surpassing piece of hardware that will eventually compete on
the software side with the features you want, and that that term might
not be as long as all that.
"It's just so hard to get psyched for that switched.
*Everything I have is Windows, my music is all MP3s, my scanner
software
is Kurzweil, my work stuff is all in Windows format, etc. I know it's
probably not as big as it sounds, but it feels big."
Yeh, I would say that your worries are not well prioritized based on a
lack of a comparison between the two systems. Kurzweil was a big hit
for me. It's a useful tool, and although there're scanning solutions
for mac, I've put so much time and money into k1000 and it's such a
nice product that I really hate to abandon it. So, I have my windows
virtual machine, and I still use k1000. Evrything else is perfectly
portable. Your mp3's, doc and docx files, excel files, email and imap
folders, Even address books and favourites copy right across the
network and are almost instantly accessible, or in many cases, there's
no almost about it. The trick to mac is that it turns your consept of
a screen reader inside-out, and so it will take you a few weeks maybe
to get used to the layout of the new OS, and the bass-ackwardness of
the screen reader. Once you are comfortable with the consept for
voice over you will love it, but most people don't love it right away.
"And then there's the price of the Mac. I'd probably get a laptop,
since cost would make
having both a laptop and a desktop prohibitive, and I get sticker-
shock
just at the thought of dropping $2000. "
Hum, well the cheepest laptops we sell start at around $1800 and go up
to about $3000. We don't usually prefer to go lower than $2500 on a
system for a client, and often that doesn't include $200-$400 worth of
accident insurance and extended warrantee coverage. That's the same
whether you get a mac or a windows system, though I think most of the
windows systems we offer aren't as nicely constructed as the mac. I
like very sleek and streamlined packages, and while the quality of our
windows systems is superb, the construction is, well, brickish. You
could get a macbook standard though and then your cost would be about
$1200 I think. That's a bit more reasonale, and the quality is just
as good. Or, if you want something to poke around on and you don't
want to break the bank, you could try a mac mini for about $600 before
deciding whether to make the switch. That would give you both a
laptop and a desktop systems for a very reasonable price.
"Out of curiosity, are Leopard 10.6 and Snow Leopard the same system?"
No, I think you have your code names and version numbers mixed up. OS
10.5 was code named leppard. OS 10.6 is code named snow leppard.
Then I confused the issue accidentally by throwing in the number
10.5.6 or in other words, mac OS10, leppard, update 6. The next full
update for mac OS will probably be snow leppard, MAC OS 10.6.0.
Best,
erik burggraaf
Certified Technician
Assistive Computing LTD Support and training
Sales department: 888-828-2445
Support and Training: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]
Website coming soon
On 18-Feb-09, at 5:56 PM, Donna Goodin wrote:
Hi Erik,
Well, I found your rant interesting *smile* As a dealer/trainer you
definitely have a different perspective and a lot more info. Buy-out?
Lawsuits? That's new on me. I can tell that FS is showing some signs
of hurt by their strong reaction to the CF products, but that's where
I've seen the most. I confess, though I agree with you about FS I
feel
a twinge of loyalty, just b/c they were there back in the 80s and 90s,
when no one else was doing that much to make anything accessible.
And I
will say, that at this point, I think the Pacmate is a more
sophisticated device than the BS--which of course also means it can
be a
lot less user-friendly.
Obviously I'm not all that enamored either with recent Windows
upgrades
or with recent versions of JAWS or I wouldn't be thinking about the
Mac.
(And no, you can't talk me into Window-Eyes *grin*). After all the
money I've sunk intoJFW over the years, it's either JAWS, or making
the
big OS switch. It's just so hard to get psyched for that switched.
*Everything I have is Windows, my music is all MP3s, my scanner
software
is Kurzweil, my work stuff is all in Windows format, etc. I know it's
probably not as big as it sounds, but it feels big. And then there's
the price of the Mac. I'd probably get a laptop, since cost would
make
having both a laptop and a desktop prohibitive, and I get sticker-
shock
just at the thought of dropping $2000. That said, it's really cool
that
Mac is making such strides with built-in braille support, and that's
something I would like to show support for. Out of curiosity, are
Leopard 10.6 and Snow Leopard the same system?
It's too bad about your clients. I've had people like you describe
ask
me for advice on getting a computer, and it's hard. I completely
agree
that if they're over 50 or 60, and don't have computer skills, JAWS is
absolutely the wrong way to go.
Well, there's my rant. I'd better get back to grading papers--though
this is much more fun!
Take care,
Donna
-----Original Message-----
From: erik burggraaf [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Wednesday, February 18, 2009 8:35 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [GWN] Braillesense and Jaws
Hi Donna,
Braille sense and sync braille are on the supported displays
list for
leppard, both as hims products and as gw products. Unfortunately I
have not been able to get the bs to co-operate, and I know of
at least
one syncbraille that hasn't toed the line. If I could afford to be
without my mac in the event of a crysis, I'd throw snow leppard beta
on here and complain vosifferously to the accessibility team if bs
support fell short in even the slightest detail. It's
bothering me in
the worst way that I can't get these products to work
together when by
all accounts they should. I love them both. My windows virtual
machine hardly gets touched any more. Apparently there are some
serious accessibility enhancements in snow leppard, including the
ability to applescript voiceover, which I didn't even realize
wasn't a
feature of os leppard. They've really done a super good job on
voiceover at this point. Now we're on os leppard 10.6, and I
can see
it growing right infront of me even in the 12 months or so that I've
owned a mac now.
I hope you go to a mac, especially since I probably can't
talk you in
to switching to window-eyes, lol. It's really too bad about
the jaws
hard ware support, and I completely disagree that it doesn't seem to
have hurt them. There was that buy out two or three years ago now.
Then there are the law suits. Then there are a lot of us
leaving the
windows platform altogether now that both orca and voiceover are not
only functional, but really comfortable and fun to use. Then we've
got nvda with support for all open source apps on the windows side,
including braille support all open source and free of charge.
We sell
every one either jaws or window-eyes, but that's really silly. Most
of our clients are over 50, Many of them have never seen or used a
computer, or haven't done for so long that the whole face of the
computer has changed since they did. They are retired or otherwise
not working, and they want something they can use to send
email to the
grand kids in BC, look up a recipe on cooks.com, and so on.
They need
jaws, or even window-eyes, like they need a kick in the pants if the
truth be told, and so I suspect that governments like mine here in
ontario and state rehab agencies have a lot more to do with the
profitability of freedom scientific than anything else. The
people in
charge of paying the bills don't use the equipment and don't really
care about 4 or 5 flavours of windows screen reader. Me, I use the
stuff, so I steer people to window-eyes when I can because I think
it's a better product, especially when some one really needs
something
reliable for work or school, but the truth is that most of my
clients
would never know the difference if we sold them system access, or
distributed computers with firefox, open office, thunderbird, nvda,
and a stand alone version of ibm via-voice. Most of them never even
stop and ask how much jaws costs. I can't tell you how many times
some one has been floored when I tell them the box price of jaws
standard. If these people were buying their own equipment I can't
imagine them buying jaws, or even, I'm sad to say, Window-eyes. Not
in today's market anyway.
Fwow I see this has gone off to quite a little rant. Anyways, I am
on this whole braille sense support thing. If there is
anything I can
do to make it happen I'll do it.
Best,
erik burggraaf
Certified Technician
Assistive Computing LTD Support and training
Sales department: 888-828-2445
Support and Training: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]
Website coming soon
On 18-Feb-09, at 4:19 PM, Donna Goodin wrote:
Hi Erik,
Thanks for the offer to throw JAWS 10 on, so far I haven't
tried it,
I've still got JAWS 9 on my office computer.
Thanks for filling me in on all the inter-adaptive tech
dynamics. I
didn't realize hardware support stopped after 4.5. That's really
short-sighted on the part of FS, it's cheaper to change your
screen-reader than it is to buy a new braille display. I understand
them
wanting people to buy their braille displays, but as much as the
things
cost, people who already own other products, simply may not
be able to
change over. I would think that would cost them customers, but
then, I
suppose if it had, they might be reconsidering their approach, and
seemingly, they are not.
I'm glad to hear you're liking the GW stuff so much. I'm
stil a bit
iffy, the inability to use it as a braille display, and the lack of
TLS
encryption for email have been sort of big issues for me. But, in
other
ways, I do really like the BS. Just curious, I keep toying with the
idea that my next computer might be a Mac. Does the BS work as a
display with Leopard?
Thanks,
Donna
-----Original Message-----
From: erik burggraaf [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Wednesday, February 18, 2009 6:40 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [GWN] Braillesense and Jaws
Hi Donna, Could you remind me what version of jaws you're
running?
If you're running 10, maybe I'll throw it on here and make
it fly and
document exactly what I'm doing. I know that's something
my clients
are liable to appreciate, and it might help you out.
Here's the deal with jaws. After version 4.5 they discontinued
support for all hardware. The braille note clasic was
current back
then and came supported out of the box. Any hardware
developed after
jaws 4.5 is not supported by jaws. That includes the
humanware/baum
stuff, the alva stuff, and of course, the marvelous braille sense.
The fact that a lot of newer devices work with jaws, and are
in fact,
really nice to use with jaws is all credit to the
manufacturers of the
hardware. Unfortunately jaws support for the braille sense is a
casualty of this arrangement. I haven't tried it, but I
don't think
focus support is all that it could be under window-eyes either. I
know there hasn't been great feeling between the two companies for
some years, but
I don't think there's any thing special there. Just a sad
lack of co-
operation, probably on more on the part of fs.
I'm really glad to have gotten into gw stuff years ago and
stuck with
it. Not a fan of the development direction of jaws for
windows, or of
freedom scientific in general as you can probably gather.
Best,
erik burggraaf
Certified Technician
Assistive Computing LTD Support and training
Sales department: 888-828-2445
Support and Training: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]
Website coming soon
On 18-Feb-09, at 3:14 PM, Donna Goodin wrote:
Hi Erik. I can't figure it out. I got your last email, and
followed
your instructions step by step. All I really want is for
it to give
me a line of braille. I use the notetaker functions in my
classroom, and
don't want to have to haul both the BS and a braille
display to work.
If it would just give me a line of braille, I wouldn't
mind at all
doing everything from the computer in my office.
Anyway, I've pretty much given up, b/c I don't know what
else to try.
So, sadly, I am hauling both a Bs and a braille display to
work after
all. If I'd known I was going to have to do that, I
probably would
not have purchased the BS.
Just curious, what's the deal between GWMicro and FS?
Doesn't JAWS
support the BrailleNote? If it supports the BrailleNote,
why not the
Braille Sense? Cheers,
Donna
-----Original Message-----
From: erik burggraaf [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Wednesday, February 18, 2009 6:04 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [GWN] Braillesense and Jaws
Hum, now it's really benighted, but it really should work,
at least
in as much as it should display a lign of braille and
let you pan
down to the next one. Beyond that it get's pretty bleak. No
bluetooth support. No braille input support. Several bugs
involving keys that
don't press in sertain combinations, and an absolutely
rediculous lack
of command structure for controlling jaws and windows.
Now granted, maybe if freedom scientific worked with hardware
manufacturers to support equipment things were better, and
window-eyes support for the braille sense is absolutely
finominal.
If you didn't
get as far as having it actually show braille though,
then there is
something else going on outside of the norm.
Best,
erik burggraaf
Certified Technician
Assistive Computing LTD Support and training
Sales department: 888-828-2445
Support and Training: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]
Website coming soon
On 18-Feb-09, at 2:18 PM, Donna Goodin wrote:
Hi Simone,
Just to add to Erik's comments here, I've been trying to
make my BS
work with JAWS for about a month now, and have had
absolutely no
success. I would second his suggestion.
Best,
Donna
-----Original Message-----
From: erik burggraaf [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Friday, February 13, 2009 8:27 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [GWN] Braillesense and Jaws
Hi, not to be disparraging, but I'd leave this if I were
you. Jaws
support for the bs is extremely poor.
Best,
erik burggraaf
Certified Technician
Assistive Computing LTD Support and training
Sales department: 888-828-2445
Support and Training: 888-255-5194
Email: [email protected]
Website coming soon
On 13-Feb-09, at 12:59 AM, Simone Dal Maso wrote:
Hi,
Since I don't want to make stupid things at my
office-work, I have a
little question. Does the driver make by Gwmicro for
Jaws support
also serial port connection? I have only Jaws6, but
I'd like to
make a test manually, but if these drivers are only for
the USB, I
don't make any test. Thanks for your patience.
--
Simone Dal Maso.
Tutti i miei progetti:
Spazioausili: consultazione, ricerca e commenti sugli ausili
informatici per non vedenti: http://www.spazioausili.net
homepage sviluppo comunita' NVDA:
www.nvda.it
Visita il mio blog!
http://simodm.blogspot.com
homepage progetto musicale:
www.juvox.it