Sharon Krossa wrote:
<snipped for convenience>
-- that is, instead of screaming "If you use this movie as a source of historical information, you're a fool", they whisper seductively "Honest, really, we're not making this up -- believe us".

Because the problem isn't that films are inaccurate -- the problem is when audiences believe what they see in films.

Sharon, this whole post was wonderful! I always laugh when people get their knickers in a twist because something in a movie is inaccurate. It's a MOVIE for pete's sake. Entertainment for the masses. History Experts are not included in "the masses". It would be nice, but it ain't so.

It's the same with fiction books. People in certain sectors get totally bent out of shape over the representation of an aspect of society and start screaming "That's Not True!" Well, *sure* -- that's why it's called a Work Of Fiction!

There are other aspects of life where history experts *aren't* knowledgeable and other incorrect details may be totally lost on them! Like a movie once where they depicted a mare having a foal, supposedly sired by a particular stallion in the movie. The color of the foal was genetically impossible from those two parents. How many people do you suppose noticed?

Well, back to costume related topics.
Denise
Iowa

_______________________________________________
h-costume mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.indra.com/mailman/listinfo/h-costume

Reply via email to