Albert said:

> That is all well and good. But this "REAL P's of the C" thing was 98% 
> reenactments. I mean it was the whole shebang. And for the reenactments to be 
> so 
> important AND the costuming to be so bad...I mean more than bad...completely 
> unprofessional! Well, there no excuse. That's my point, really



______________

Gotta chime in here.  The re-enactors were the foot soldiers; they were 
responsible for their own clothing, which represents many research hours and 
many dollars to get authenticity to the highest level possible.  Take a look at 
the battle and seige scenes in The Southern Strategy" episode and the upcoming 
ones depicting the war in the South.  I believe you will be hard pressed to 
find fault with the clothing worn by the soldiers (except for that guy with the 
cigarette in the first episode--don't know where HE came from,).  As one who 
was there during the filming of the Charleston scenes (if you look reeeaaallly 
fast, you can see my brown silk taffeta sacqueback in some of the dance clips), 
 I can attest to the importance attached to getting the clothing, arms, and 
camps as close to authentic as possible.

I think the ones you are finding fault with are the named characters, who are 
paid actors and costumed by the production company.  The company is interested 
in a good scene, and if it happens to have good costuming (darned few and far 
between in this production) that is a chance happening.

To their credit, the production company made an effort at authenticity by 
hiring as a consultant a well-respected re-enactor / scholar to advise them on 
the military scenes and clothing.  He was extremely frustrated because, talk 
though he might, they weren't interested if it did not fit their idea of the 
scene.  To my knowledge, neither he nor anyone else advised about the costuming 
of the paid cast.  There couldn't have been anyone--otherwise they would not 
all be running around with (Jo-Ann) lace jabots and dead cats on their heads.

Several re-enactors lent or rented clothing or firearms to the productiion 
company.  When--if--they got them back, the items had been very poorly treated  
and in some cases ruined (despite the costuming departments promises to the 
contrary, spray-on "stage dirt" IS permanent).  

On the other hand, there are some interesting touches.  One re-enactor, a 
member of the group which portrays the Coldstream Guards, let them use his 
officer's dress coat, which a documented copy of a Guards coat of the war 
period,. So far it has turned up on both General Burgoyne and General Clinton.  
He is sure that Clinton must be spinning in his grave, to have been seen in a 
Guards uniform.  Keep an eye out for further sightings--the Guards uniform was 
more elaborate than many of the uniforms worn by the AWI generals.  So you will 
know the coat--it is the one with all the gold braid.

Jane Pease
_______________________________________________
h-costume mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.indra.com/mailman/listinfo/h-costume

Reply via email to