Seems to me that wiki pages are absurdly cheap and we're better off encouraging participation than discouraging it.

As for noise from wiki update notifications, that must be a subscriber choice because I don't get them. For folks who don't like them I suggest turning that option off. Also wikis typically have sandboxes for just this purpose, and certainly there is no need for the list to be notified of changes there.

Communication with folks for whom English is not their first language, and are just starting to use Internet collaboration tools to boot, can be somewhat challenging for all involved. I would hope the Hadoop project develops a culture of tolerance rather than harsh criticism.

My 1/50th of a buck.

Jim

edward yoon wrote:

Greetings guys,

I wrote some stuff in wiki page last night to share, to disscuss and get feedbacks about my views in BigTable. ...
    From: /Otis Gospodnetic <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>/
...
    Wed, 14 Feb 2007 22:16:26 PST/
     >Hola,
     >
     >How come Jim and udanax are using Wiki for discussion? Maybe it's
    just me, but I find it extra difficult to follow a discussion that
    comes to the list as a wiki diff message. :) Why not discuss this on
    hadoop-dev?
...

Doug Cutting wrote:
Apache Wiki wrote:

The following page has been changed by udanax: http://wiki.apache.org/lucene-hadoop/Bigtable%26Sawzall + ''Thank
you for commenting JimKellerman. The reason is.. First, Now i'm
getting exercise for the Wiki. i'm unskilled. :-) and Second.. May
be, We can think about it differently. So, I can't edit rashly your
page. But finally, I wanna be linking to your page and editing with
collaboration from members.'' + ''And.. I have a question. How can
i center-align embedded-image?''--[wiki:udanax Udanax]


Udanax,

Please do not use the Hadoop wiki for practicing and learning to use
a wiki. It is an important part of the Hadoop project infrastructure.
 Each change to the wiki results in email to 240 people. Changes to
the wiki should thus be restricted to things that are useful to the
project.

If you have questions about the project, the mailing lists are best
for discussion: hadoop-user for how-to questions; and hadoop-dev for
design and implementation discussions.

Thanks,

Doug



Reply via email to