[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HADOOP-941?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel#action_12475916
]
Doug Cutting commented on HADOOP-941:
-------------------------------------
> dependency on the Lucene jar. Which was deemed unacceptable, so we copied
> Lucene's PriorityQueue
I didn't like that change, since it duplicated code. But the duplication was
across projects, and thus harder to avoid, and it fixed a serious bug, that
Hadoop-based applications that wanted to use a different version of Lucene from
the one in Hadoop could not easily do so, as the version included in Hadoop was
found first on the class path. So the cost seemed worth the benefit. But here
I don't see any serious functional bug that implementing Writable and
WritableComparable causes. Perhaps, somewhere down the line, such a bug will
emerge, and we'll take on what source-code complexity is required to fix it
then. But, perhaps again, we'll never have to. Let's wait and see. None of
the arguments I have heard (package names, generated code size, jar file size)
yet constitute bugs worthy of fixing unless the cost of the fix is negligible.
The record code generation is likely to get more complex as time passes, to add
features that fix real problems. Making it more complex now has a
combinatorial effect on our ability to maintain this code: more conditional
branches to edit, more modes to test, more features to document, etc. The
long-term cost of adding code complexity are much greater than, e.g., the
long-term costs of slightly larger generated code size.
> Make Hadoop Record I/O Easier to use outside Hadoop
> ---------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: HADOOP-941
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HADOOP-941
> Project: Hadoop
> Issue Type: Improvement
> Components: record
> Affects Versions: 0.10.1
> Environment: All
> Reporter: Milind Bhandarkar
> Assigned To: Milind Bhandarkar
> Attachments: jute-patch.txt
>
>
> Hadoop record I/O can be used effectively outside of Hadoop. It would
> increase its utility if developers can use it without having to import hadoop
> classes, or having to depend on Hadoop jars. Following changes to the current
> translator and runtime are proposed.
> Proposed Changes:
> 1. Use java.lang.String as a native type for ustring (instead of Text.)
> 2. Provide a Buffer class as a native Java type for buffer (instead of
> BytesWritable), so that later BytesWritable could be implemented as following
> DDL:
> module org.apache.hadoop.io {
> record BytesWritable {
> buffer value;
> }
> }
> 3. Member names in generated classes should not have prefixes 'm' before
> their names. In the above example, the private member name would be 'value'
> not 'mvalue' as it is done now.
> 4. Convert getters and setters to have CamelCase. e.g. in the above example
> the getter will be:
> public Buffer getValue();
> 5. Provide a 'swiggable' C binding, so that processing the generated C code
> with swig allows it to be used in scripting languages such as Python and Perl.
> 6. The default --language="java" target would generate class code for records
> that would not have Hadoop dependency on WritableComparable interface, but
> instead would have "implements Record, Comparable". (i.e. It will not have
> write() and readFields() methods.) An additional option "--writable" will
> need to be specified on rcc commandline to generate classes that "implements
> Record, WritableComparable".
> 7. Optimize generated write() and readFields() methods, so that they do not
> have to create BinaryOutputArchive or BinaryInputArchive every time these
> methods are called on a record.
> 8. Implement ByteInStream and ByteOutStream for C++ runtime, as they will be
> needed for using Hadoop Record I/O with forthcoming C++ MapReduce framework
> (currently, only FileStreams are provided.)
> 9. Generate clone() methods for records in Java i.e. the generated classes
> should implement Cloneable.
> 10. As part of Hadoop build process, produce a tar bundle for Record I/O
> alone. This tar bundle will contain the translator classes and ant task
> (lib/rcc.jar), translator script (bin/rcc), Java runtime (recordio.jar) that
> includes org.apache.hadoop.record.*, sources for the java runtime (src/java),
> and c/c++ runtime sources with Makefiles (src/c++, src/c).
> 11. Make generated Java codes for maps and vectors use Java generics.
> These are the proposed user-visible changes. Internally, the translator will
> be restructured so that it is easier to plug-in translators for different
> targets.
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
