Hi Please find attached new test result using httpress tool. Configuration is remain same for both nginx and haproxy shared earlier.
Summary Report *Haproxy:* TOTALS: 5000 connect, 5000 requests, 5000 success, 0 fail, 500 (500) real concurrency TRAFFIC: 10 avg bytes, 230 avg overhead, 50000 bytes, 1150000 overhead TIMING: 25.253 seconds, 197 rps, 46 kbps, 2525.3 ms avg req time *Nginx:* TOTALS: 5000 connect, 5000 requests, 5000 success, 0 fail, 500 (500) real concurrency TRAFFIC: 10 avg bytes, 230 avg overhead, 50000 bytes, 1150000 overhead TIMING: 6.439 seconds, 776 rps, 181 kbps, 643.9 ms avg req time On Tue, Oct 4, 2016 at 2:24 PM, Rajesh Mahajan <[email protected]> wrote: > Please check the ssl_haproxy.cfg .We have defined max value as below > > global > maxconn 20000 > maxconnrate 15000 > > On Tue, Oct 4, 2016 at 2:03 PM, Marcin Deranek <[email protected] > > wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> On Tue, 4 Oct 2016 10:55:08 +0530 >> Rajesh Mahajan <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> > Please find attached configuration files for both nginx and haproxy. >> > Could you please share your results wrt to nginx and tell me which >> > http benchmark tool you are using for testing. >> >> From what I see you did not specify maxconn limit in defaults >> nor frontend sections, so effectively you will be limited to 2000 >> concurrent connections on frontend (we run into this problem during our >> tests). >> >> Due to the fact that we needed to test our setup up to 10Gb/s we had to >> build our own tools as currently available scaled "only" up to ~2-3Gb/s. >> We >> used multi-threaded tools like wrk2, httpress (with some patches) and >> weighttp as a starting point and build scripts around them to aggregate >> data from multiple machines running those. I started to prefer httpress >> (with some patches) as it allows to test keepalive/non-keepalive >> connections (as opposite to wrk2). On the other hand wrk2 has some nice >> Lua scripting capabilities which might be useful in certain scenarios >> like replaying traffic. >> >> Unfortunately right now I cannot find any "trustworthy" results we have >> obtained while comparing HAProxy and nginx. During our testing we >> discovered that Nginx does not scale linearly when increasing amount of >> workers - it was even worse: increasing amount of workers degraded >> performance. Later this problem was mitigated, but not completely >> resolved resulting up to 20% performance degradation with 24 >> cores/workers running. Proper fix would require significant >> architectural changes of Nginx, so we were left only with a workaround. >> Overall HAProxy and nginx were comparable (HAProxy still faster), but >> due to above bug nginx was visibly behind when number of workers >> increased. When we decided to use HAProxy our focus moved towards >> tuning HAProxy rather than comparing HAProxy and nginx. We have some >> data on our Wiki from time when we compared HAProxy and nginx, but >> setup and performance isn't nowhere near what we currently use/get >> (Those benchmarks did not use our distributed benchmark infrastructure >> to obtain results, so effectively they were limited to 1Gb/s of traffic >> due to network interface throughput). >> Regards, >> >> Marcin >> > >
======================== HAPROXY ============================================ httpress -n 5000 -t 100 -c 500 https://192.168.57.30/test.html 1250 requests launched 2500 requests launched 3750 requests launched 5000 requests launched thread 20: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 18: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 27: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 5: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 16: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 15: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 4: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 30: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 22: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 21: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 31: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 24: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 25: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 26: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 29: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 43: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 34: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 33: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 38: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 28: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 44: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 37: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 45: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 39: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 32: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 40: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 35: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 41: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 42: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 36: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 23: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 60: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 61: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 46: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 50: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 7: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 10: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 54: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 53: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 49: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 99: 46 connect, 46 requests, 46 success, 0 fail, 460 bytes, 10580 overhead thread 51: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 3: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 52: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 65: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 71: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 56: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 47: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 48: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 62: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 55: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 94: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 91: 47 connect, 47 requests, 47 success, 0 fail, 470 bytes, 10810 overhead thread 82: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 57: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 85: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 78: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 17: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 9: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 19: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 68: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 100: 47 connect, 47 requests, 47 success, 0 fail, 470 bytes, 10810 overhead thread 8: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 63: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 59: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 73: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 67: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 86: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 70: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 75: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 77: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 66: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 76: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 84: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 74: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 14: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 6: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 58: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 81: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 64: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 88: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 93: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 69: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 80: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 92: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 72: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 83: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 96: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 13: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 12: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 98: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 1: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 2: 54 connect, 54 requests, 54 success, 0 fail, 540 bytes, 12420 overhead thread 79: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 87: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 89: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 11: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 97: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 95: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 90: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead SSL INFO: DHE_RSA_AES_256_CBC_SHA1 - Protocol: TLS1.0 - Key Exchange: DHE-RSA - Ephemeral DH using prime of 2048 bits - Cipher: AES-256-CBC - MAC: SHA1 - Compression: NULL - Certificate Type: X.509 - Certificate Info: subject `C=AU,ST=Some-State,O=Internet Widgits Pty Ltd,CN=api.test.in', issuer `C=AU,ST=Some-State,O=Internet Widgits Pty Ltd,CN=api.test.in', RSA key 2048 bits, signed using RSA-SHA256, activated `2016-09-21 12:05:24 UTC', expires `2026-09-19 12:05:24 UTC', SHA-1 fingerprint `60b99cbb34a580c0923dd6b83a4e947143ced684' TOTALS: 5000 connect, 5000 requests, 5000 success, 0 fail, 500 (500) real concurrency TRAFFIC: 10 avg bytes, 230 avg overhead, 50000 bytes, 1150000 overhead TIMING: 25.253 seconds, 197 rps, 46 kbps, 2525.3 ms avg req time ============================================ NGINX PERFORMANCE ===================== httpress -n 5000 -t 100 -c 500 https://192.168.57.30:8443/test.html 1250 requests launched 2500 requests launched 3750 requests launched 5000 requests launched thread 12: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 17: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 5: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 29: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 14: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 27: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 37: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 22: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 23: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 28: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 36: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 26: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 34: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 38: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 46: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 6: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 43: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 39: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 51: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 40: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 30: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 35: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 44: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 50: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 45: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 49: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 58: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 33: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 63: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 61: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 54: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 42: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 52: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 55: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 66: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 67: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 60: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 41: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 48: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 47: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 69: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 10: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 65: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 2: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 57: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 64: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 68: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 62: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 4: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 97: 47 connect, 47 requests, 47 success, 0 fail, 470 bytes, 10810 overhead thread 80: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 53: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 59: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 72: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 20: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 77: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 15: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 18: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 21: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 91: 47 connect, 47 requests, 47 success, 0 fail, 470 bytes, 10810 overhead thread 56: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 94: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 31: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 70: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 71: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 16: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 89: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 25: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 24: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 76: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 84: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 88: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 99: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 92: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 1: 53 connect, 53 requests, 53 success, 0 fail, 530 bytes, 12190 overhead thread 85: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 78: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 98: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 74: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 79: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 96: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 13: 54 connect, 54 requests, 54 success, 0 fail, 540 bytes, 12420 overhead thread 3: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 8: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 100: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 86: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 87: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 93: 47 connect, 47 requests, 47 success, 0 fail, 470 bytes, 10810 overhead thread 90: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 9: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 82: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 73: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 7: 52 connect, 52 requests, 52 success, 0 fail, 520 bytes, 11960 overhead thread 81: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead thread 32: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 11: 53 connect, 53 requests, 53 success, 0 fail, 530 bytes, 12190 overhead thread 95: 48 connect, 48 requests, 48 success, 0 fail, 480 bytes, 11040 overhead thread 19: 51 connect, 51 requests, 51 success, 0 fail, 510 bytes, 11730 overhead thread 75: 49 connect, 49 requests, 49 success, 0 fail, 490 bytes, 11270 overhead thread 83: 50 connect, 50 requests, 50 success, 0 fail, 500 bytes, 11500 overhead SSL INFO: DHE_RSA_3DES_EDE_CBC_SHA1 - Protocol: TLS1.0 - Key Exchange: DHE-RSA - Ephemeral DH using prime of 1024 bits - Cipher: 3DES-CBC - MAC: SHA1 - Compression: NULL - Certificate Type: X.509 - Certificate Info: subject `C=IN,ST=INDIA,L=Default City,O=Default Company Ltd,CN=api.spicesafar.com', issuer `C=IN,ST=INDIA,L=Default City,O=Default Company Ltd,CN=api.spicesafar.com', RSA key 2048 bits, signed using RSA-SHA1, activated `2016-09-20 10:12:21 UTC', expires `2017-09-20 10:12:21 UTC', SHA-1 fingerprint `3ca493533b91b6495a1ec1df76e04518ac14f14e' TOTALS: 5000 connect, 5000 requests, 5000 success, 0 fail, 500 (500) real concurrency TRAFFIC: 10 avg bytes, 230 avg overhead, 50000 bytes, 1150000 overhead TIMING: 6.439 seconds, 776 rps, 181 kbps, 643.9 ms avg req time
