Hi Shawn.
On 2023-05-28 (So.) 05:30, Shawn Heisey wrote:
On 5/27/23 18:03, Shawn Heisey wrote:
On 5/27/23 14:56, Shawn Heisey wrote:
Yup. It was using keepalive. I turned keepalive off and repeated
the tests.
I did the tests again with 200 threads. The system running the tests
has 12 hyperthreaded cores, so this definitely pushes its capabilities.
I had forgotten a crucial fact that means all my prior testing work was
invalid: Apache HttpClient 4.x defaults to a max simultaneous
connection count of 2. Not going to exercise concurrency with that!
I have increased that to 1024, my program's max thread count, and now
the test is a LOT faster ... it's actually running 200 threads at the
same time. Two runs per branch here, one with 200 threads and one with
24 threads.
Still no smoking gun showing 3.0 as the slowest of the bunch. In fact,
3.0 is giving the best results! So my test method is still probably the
wrong approach.
Maybe you can change the setup in that way
HAProxies FE => HAProxies BE => Destination Servers
Where the Destination Servers are also HAProxies which just returns a
static content or any high performance low latency HTTPS Server.
With such a Setup can you test also the Client mode of the OpenSSL.
Regards
Alex
1.1.1t:
21:06:45.388 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Count 200000 234.54/s
21:06:45.388 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 10th % 54 ms
21:06:45.388 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 25th % 94 ms
21:06:45.389 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Median 188 ms
21:06:45.389 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 75th % 991 ms
21:06:45.389 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 95th % 3698 ms
21:06:45.389 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99th % 6924 ms
21:06:45.390 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99.9 % 11983 ms
-
21:20:35.400 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Count 24000 355.56/s
21:20:35.400 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 10th % 40 ms
21:20:35.401 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 25th % 46 ms
21:20:35.401 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Median 57 ms
21:20:35.401 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 75th % 71 ms
21:20:35.401 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 95th % 126 ms
21:20:35.401 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99th % 168 ms
21:20:35.401 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99.9 % 721 ms
3.0.8:
20:50:12.916 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Count 200000 244.69/s
20:50:12.917 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 10th % 56 ms
20:50:12.917 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 25th % 93 ms
20:50:12.917 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Median 197 ms
20:50:12.917 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 75th % 949 ms
20:50:12.918 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 95th % 3425 ms
20:50:12.918 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99th % 6679 ms
20:50:12.918 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99.9 % 11582 ms
-
21:23:22.076 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Count 24000 404.78/s
21:23:22.077 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 10th % 40 ms
21:23:22.077 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 25th % 45 ms
21:23:22.077 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Median 53 ms
21:23:22.077 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 75th % 63 ms
21:23:22.077 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 95th % 90 ms
21:23:22.077 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99th % 121 ms
21:23:22.078 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99.9 % 671 ms
3.1.0+locks:
20:33:32.805 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Count 200000 238.02/s
20:33:32.806 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 10th % 58 ms
20:33:32.806 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 25th % 95 ms
20:33:32.806 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Median 196 ms
20:33:32.806 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 75th % 1001 ms
20:33:32.807 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 95th % 3475 ms
20:33:32.807 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99th % 6288 ms
20:33:32.807 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99.9 % 10700 ms
-
21:26:24.555 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Count 24000 402.89/s
21:26:24.556 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 10th % 39 ms
21:26:24.556 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 25th % 45 ms
21:26:24.556 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest Median 52 ms
21:26:24.556 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 75th % 64 ms
21:26:24.556 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 95th % 93 ms
21:26:24.556 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99th % 127 ms
21:26:24.557 [main] INFO o.e.t.h.MainSSLTest 99.9 % 689 ms
