On Mon, Apr 05, 2004 at 01:59:18PM +0200, Henning Thielemann wrote: > In addition I separated a class VectorSpacePure from the VectorSpace > class that contains the operations that don't need the scalar type 'a', > i.e. 'zero' and 'add'.
I called this class 'Additive' in my old proposal to revamp the numeric hierarchy of the basic Prelude, and made 'Num' inherit from it: http://www.haskell.org/pipermail/haskell-cafe/2001-February/001632.html (Perhaps I should revive this proposal. I have been using a newer version in my own programs, but I didn't see a way to actually get it widely adopted. In particular, the design I proposed is somewhat annoying to use because there's no defaulting and you have to add an explicit type whenever you raise a number to an explicit integer power.) > Further I swapped consistently 'a' and 'v' in the class definition > and in the quantity data type, i.e. "class VectorSpace a v" and > "data Quantity a v". I suppose that it will more oftenly be > necessary to say something about the vectors that can built from a > certain scalar (i.e. Quantity a) rather than about the scalar types > that can be the base of a vector type. Yes, that's a good choice. > > By the way, depending how you resolve the issue above, you might want > > instead > > > > > instance (RealFloat a, VectorSpace b a) => VectorSpace [b] a where > > > ... > > That's really a nice generalization! With the specialised instances for > Float and Double as shown above this works. Now I can built VectorSpace > over several levels, e.g. a list of complex numbers as vectors with > respect to real numbers. But it prohibits functional dependency, right? No, it shouldn't, if you do it right. > Functional dependency would probably allow the compiler to detect which > scalar type is associated with an vector and thus the compiler wouldn't > ask me to tell it explicitly all the time. Yes. That's what you want if you only have one scalar type for a given vector space. > Maybe a type class like the VectorSpace finds the way to a revised version > of Prelude? I didn't include it in my proposal, because it uses multi-parameter type classes, which are not in nhc, for instance. I don't know that it should be in the Prelude, but in the standard library. There are a few design issues, as you noticed; it's particularly annoying that you can't easily right 'instance (Num a) => VectorSpace a a'. Peace, Dylan
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature
_______________________________________________ Haskell-Cafe mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.haskell.org/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe
