Earlier in this thread I wrote "... but like so what." In this letter I hope to
address what I wrote more fully.
The command line option that was found that allows for Haskell source code to
be preprocessed accepts a Haskell source code file as an argument. This file
defines a preprocessor. It seems to me that such a preprocessor would be
undisciplined and capable of wrong doing because the Haskell language does not
have all the facilities that a utility such as Happy possesses. Care is needed.
It also lacks those facilities that are particular to preprocessors.
The paper at http://people.cs.uu.nl/arthurb/data/Macros/Manual.pdf may provide
a means to introduce this needed discipline. I do not see how the runtime
verses compile time distinction is important, however. You can't really hand
craft a preprocessor on the fly that is going to work. I do not believe the
paper is explaining itself all that well. What they are referring to as syntax
macros given a superficial examination of the paper seem to be the functional
language equivalent of a definite clause grammar found in Prolog. So it seems
that an effort to bring that goodness that Prolog programmers have enjoyed for
years over to Haskell and perhaps to do one or two better.
Their emphasis on runtime verses compile time seems like a distraction in that
it is merely a necessary condition for inclusion into the Haskell language
since Haskell is both compiled and interpreted. It is a problem that would need
to be solved. They may have lost sight of what they were doing after having
spent so much time working on just this one aspect. Haskell at the present time
need external tools. The benefits of bringing in that sort of functionality
into the language I would regard as self-evident.
It is still a bottom up approach, but a bottom up approach would be easier to
implement and it would be desirable for the two worlds to meet, the bottom up
and the top down.
An important question will be, Will syntax macros work out better than an
existing tool such as Happy?
_______________________________________________
Haskell-Cafe mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.haskell.org/mailman/listinfo/haskell-cafe