Hi Daniel and Ray,

>>> I've noticed that h5dump seems to truncate comments.

>> I reported this bug several weeks ago, so I think the answer is "there is no
>> switch to fix it."

> One of us is working on it.

Thank you!

>> Actually, I don't understand the reason for the existence of the object
>> comment facility.   Is there a substantive difference between a comment and
>> an HDF5 attribute called, say, "COMMENT"?

Functionally, nothing.  Conceptually, lots.  Comments are for humans
and attributes are for machines.  Analogously, in C-speak one could
claim that both of

A) static const char cmt1[] = "Some pertinent comment";
B) /* Some pertinent comment */

are functionally equivalent.  Obviously, they're conceptually quite
distinct.  Fortunately, the C language folks decided to not make
programmers simulate comments via other language functionality.

> Actually, the library has deprecated comment in favor of attributes.

Say it ain't so!  There's unlimited goodness to be gained by having an
unambiguous comment facility!

- Rhys

_______________________________________________
Hdf-forum is for HDF software users discussion.
[email protected]
http://mail.hdfgroup.org/mailman/listinfo/hdf-forum_hdfgroup.org

Reply via email to