Heime <[email protected]> writes:

> On Friday, May 15th, 2026 at 8:56 PM, Nicolas Goaziou 
> <[email protected]> wrote:

>> However I strongly discourage from installing `texlive-scheme-full'. 
>> I don’t know your use case but you probably do not need at least 
>> 80% of the packages it provides (e.g., I assume you don’t write 
>> a thesis for 60 universities across the world). 
>
> If the current distribution strategy for TeX Live is indeed as 
> described, the people at texlive have really lost the plot.  A 
> departure from a user-centric design that fails to provide a 
> stable, foundational release creates substantial hurdles for 
> users attempting to establish a functional environment.
>
> The influence of academic and institutional priorities, has 
> complicated the installation process to the point of frustration, 
> effectively obscuring the primary goal of providing a reliable 
> typesetting system.

User-centric design is difficult to achieve when user needs can widely vary. In 
any case, TeX Live (and therefore Guix) provides different ways to obtain a 
reliable typesetting system. None of them is difficult to follow.

- You can install a single package and forget about it, like you already do;

- You can choose a reasonable set of "collections" and occasionally install 
manually a package you’re missing out. For example, since you are a Lua(La)TeX 
user, installing texlive-collection-luatex, 
texlive-collection-latexrecommended, and texlive-collection-pictures (for 
PGF/TikZ) is a good start.

- You can select only a couple of low level collections and only install 
individual packages you really need.

It depends on your needs and the time on your hands.

>> Instead, I suggest to select a few so-called collections of packages 
>> you may be interested in, such as `texlive-collection-latexrecommended', 
>> and possibly add some dependencies manually (in particular those 
>> coming from "latexextra" collection, which is huge) when compilation 
>> asks about them. At some point your setup will stabilize and you will 
>> end up managing Mo instead of Go of TeX packages.
>
> Is the selection via Guix?

Of course. You can choose the granularity of your TeX Live installation. You 
can install a scheme, such as texlive-scheme-medium, collections, such as 
texlive-collection-pictures, and individual packages. And you can mix all of 
those.

Or you can install the 4k+ packages from texlive-scheme-full, which is a 
no-brainer but could also be a waste (of bandwidth, disk space…).

Regards,



Reply via email to