%% "Shipman, Alister" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: sa> I think this problem may have been mentioned in relation to bug sa> 1517.
It's possible, but you haven't provided any examples of what you're really trying to do so I can't say. sa> I am trying to implement the example shown in section 8.8 of the sa> manual. However when I try and use the foreach function I get sa> "missing separator" errors. I can use foreach on its own sa> e.g $(foreach library,$(LIBRARYS), $(warning $(library))) sa> However if I try even a variable assignment in it it has issues sa> e.g: file_list := sa> $(foreach library,$(LIBRARYS), file_list+=$(library)) I don't think this is what you want. Given a value of LIBRARYS (note generally spelled "LIBRARIES" :)) like this: LIBRARYS = foo bar baz then your foreach above expands to this: file_list+=foo file_list+=bar file_list+=baz which may not be a syntax error but I daresay is not anything like what you wanted to do. On the other hand, this works for me: $ cat Makefile LIBRARYS := foo bar baz file_list := $(foreach lib,$(LIBRARYS),$(eval file_list += $(lib))) all: ; @echo $(file_list) $ make foo bar baz sa> The function I have setup to produce my make code, analogous to sa> PROGRAM_template, performs fine when I use plain arguments to it sa> (i.e I just use $(eval $(call PROGRAM_template, someProgramName)), sa> and is fine when I do the same with the function argument as the sa> contents of a variable, but place it within a foreach call and it sa> has issues too (missing separator issues) I need to see something that emulates what you're _REALLY_ trying to do, and gives the same error message you're getting, not something that doesn't resemble it at all and has very different behavior. sa> I'd really like to use this functionality - could you please sa> either direct me to a workaround (a different way of looping sa> through a set of names), I don't have any good suggestions. sa> a patch if it exists already, It's attached to the (closed) bug report in Savannah. Unfortunately, it seems like looking at bug details in Savannah has been broken since Tuesday or so. There was also a prerelease of the next version of GNU make, although there is still some functionality missing from it, at the alpha site but due to crackers infiltrating the GNU systems all that content is offline while they verify that it hasn't been compromised. sa> or an indication of when a next release might be.... Sorry, I'm not sure. I was hoping to get some work done on it in July but didn't; now I'm hoping to find time near the end of this month to get a release candidate for 3.81 out. -- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Paul D. Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Find some GNU make tips at: http://www.gnu.org http://make.paulandlesley.org "Please remain calm...I may be mad, but I am a professional." --Mad Scientist _______________________________________________ Help-make mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://mail.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/help-make
