I know that " In America nothing is impossible " but I have serious doubts about the presence of a
hurdy gurdy at the time of the civil war .

I am a HG player and a F&I war re-enactor , I still hope to find a solid evidence of a HG in New France ( 1600-1759) wich is the Baroque music period , but so far found only one mention of a HG player who made his own instrument in Louisbourg 1750 , in present day Nova Scotia . quite far from the Montréal area . and another mention for Québec city in 1632 , the one shown in the film " Black Robe " .
( in " Relations des Jésuites " year 1632 )

In the american civil war period , where would the HG come from ? what model could it be ? who would play it ? what rerertoire ? If it was that popular at the time , how come almost
nobody in the US knows what it is today ?

Henry

   http://fortress.uccb.ns.ca/Search/fprim5.html

Gary F. Plazyk a écrit :

Hi, Barry!

It all depends on who you are talking to about it... For a fascinating look at both the war and the people that reenact it, check out _Confederates in the Attic : Dispatches from the Unfinished Civil War_ by Tony Horwitz.

I have only been to reenactments in the Midwest - not the really serious ones that take place at the historic battle sites - and have seen a whole spectrum of participants, from families that attend for a weekend-long combination campout and costume party, to serious historical reenactors that demand period thread-count in their clothing and live in their costumes for weeks at a time to get a "period high". I'm much more middle of the road - I wear period costume, play (more or less) period music, and they feed me. I like to think a fun time is had by all.

Best regards,

-Gary P.

Barry Black wrote:

Wasn't that the "war of northern aggression"?


Reply via email to