[Note: Ali Sina (a fake name) is no more than a mental patient having rabies
behavior who has been attacking Islam, Muslims and Prophet Muhammad in the most
evil and sinister ways from rat-hole since 9-11 drama. He was told by his
masters that the Quran and Prophet Muhammad did it! Since then he has been
barking against Prophet Muhammad like a rabid dog. He is not just a critic of
Islam and Muhammad. He is MUCH more than that. He repeatedly says that he has
no problem with other religions, their followers and founders. They are all
like angels to him. He also promotes his masters' religion! His only
target is Islam, Muslims and Prophet Muhammad. He has been given the task
to eradicate Islam from the face of the earth and to convert all Muslims to his
masters' religion! So far, he has been able to convert some foolhardy clowns
from poor and unfortunate Muzlim, not Muslim, background like Syed Kamran
Mirza, Asghar, Abul Kasem etc. who were
never Muslim in the first place and they also write against Islam,
Muslims and Prophet Muhammad from rat-hole to please their masters! He
gets very angry and frustrated when he sees thousands of westerners converting
to Islam every year! But he becomes very happy when he hears some poor and
foolhardy Muzlims converting to his masters' religion! His masters are not that
happy on their slave's very poor and idiotic performance though! Anyway, please
go through Al-Ansar's open letter to this mental patient.]
An Open Letter to Ali Sina by Al-Ansar
http://muslim-responses.com/Letter/Letter_
Hello Mr Ali Sina,
I was surprised when I visited your website Mr Sina, when I encountered such
ignorance and blatant disregard for the truth. You amaze me Mr Sina. You are
one of the few people who I have encountered with such a naive and idiotic
viewpoint towards worldly affairs and the religion of Islam. Indeed it is
amazing how someone with no training in Islamic scholarship and obviously
lacking in some of the most basic aspects of Islamic knowledge would have the
arrogance to challenge the greatest scholars of Islam for a debate. The amount
of arrogance that an anonymous person off of the internet could carry is
astounding, considering the fact that you actually expect the great scholars to
come to your little-known forum and play by your rules of the debate. You also
refuse to debate Muslims in public or even on audio, citing safety concerns. It
truly is amazing how cowardly a man like you can be Mr Sina. People like Wafa
Sultan and Robert Spencer regularly appear
on national television cursing Islam, yet they haven't been assassinated have
they? Mr Sina, your arguments would be laughed at by the great scholars and
they will dismiss you as a delusional man with too much time on his hands.
Surely it is obvious that no one can ever "win" a debate against you, since you
are the judge of your own debates and you are the one who decides whether the
Muslim was successful or not. Therefore, your "challenge" is subjective as well
as illogical. And no Mr Sina, the public is not the judge of your debates,
since you aren't exactly mailing ballots to all those who visit your website.
Exactly what are you accomplishing Mr Sina from spending so much effort into
your website? How many Muslims have you managed to make denounce Islam? 4? 5?
Maybe 10? How is this "accomplishment" going to solve the problem of world
peace?
How is reaching back 14 centuries to assess the life of a 7th century Bedouin
going to solve the problem of world peace? If you truly were against Islam
because, "It orders it's followers to kill all non-believers", then you would
focus on the aspects of political Islam, and it's effects and causes, instead
of worrying about the life of a man who isn't even here to defend himself
personally. Even if your Muslim challenger does "disprove" all of your charges,
exactly what is the end result Mr Sina? Ok suddenly, a man who lived 1400 years
ago isn't a criminal. Now tell me how such matters are important at all.
Shouldn't the character of Muhammad strictly be a topic discussed amongst the
Muslims, since it affects only them and no one else? And even if he wasn't a
criminal as you claim, then this does not prove his Prophethood. I'm not a
murderer, rapist, sex-offender or robber; does this mean that I am a Prophet? I
can't believe you aren't able to see how
stupid this challenge is. And reaching back into history to assess the life of
a 7th century man isn't exactly going to solve the "problem" of political
Islam. You even said on your website, "I oppose Islam because it tells it's
followers to kill Non-Muslims." Well if that were true, then there is no point
and end-goal of studying the life of Muhammad. If we do disprove these charges,
the disproval will not "prove" that political Islam doesn't advocate the deaths
of all Non-Believers.
After all, if you truly were against Islam for these reasons, then you would
focus solely on the "intolerant" verses of the Quran and the actions of
modern-day Muslims. No, you set up this website because you want to legitimize
your trashing of a man who isn't even alive to defend himself personally. You
haven't been able to prove that he harmed ANYONE who didn't directly harm him
at first, and even the Quran states clearly that we are only allowed to fight
those who fight us first (2:190) There are those of your disciples who claim
that Surah 2:190 was "abrogated" by Surah 9, although a close reading of Surah
9 again proves that Jihad is only a defensive warfare against those who harm
the Muslim nation or those who practice injustice. Hence, if you study Islamic
history, you would notice that the early Muslims did not wage war against the
Abyssinian Empire, although we did have the means and capability of doing so.
These facts alone demolish your entire basis of attacking Islam as a religion
which authorizes the unjustified attacks of Non-Muslim nations. And if you were
against Islam because of these reasons, then why don't you study the teachings
of the Jewish scriptures which DO authorize the murder of Non-Believers?
Certainly, a study of the Old Testament proves that Old Testament figures such
as Moses and Joshua DO have a lot of blood on their hands. Biblical verses such
as 2 Chronicles 15:13 don't bother you at all, because you are selective in
your criticism and you hypocritically attack Islam for aspects which are also
found in other religions. It is obvious that you do not want to bite the hand
that feeds you. And on what basis are you levying your charges against the Holy
Prophet anyway? Who do you think you are, sitting on your chair assuming that
you are judge, jury and executioner of an unfair and illogical debate and then
arrogantly assume that Muslims
all over the world do not have the ability to take you on in a debate. You
complain about Muslim presence in Western nations, such as Canada and the USA,
although there are Non-Muslim MILITARY BASES on our soil. Certainly you cannot
find any Iranian warships patrolling the beaches of Los Angeles or Maine. The
Muslims in the West arrive with passports and suitcases, while the Non-Muslims
in the Islamic world arrive with tanks and warships. So what right do you have
to complain about the rapid growth of mosques all over the USA and Canada, when
your military presence is found all over the Middle East!!
And you are a man who is not disturbed by the massacres carried out in
Palestine, in Kashmir, in Bosnia, in Chechnya, and in Mogadishu, because the
victims here are Muslims being massacred by Non-Muslims! After all, you claim
that Muslims are the ones doing the killing all over the world and these are
one of the reasons why you oppose Islam. You condemn the killing of Nick Berg
whilst turning a blind eye to those who drop napalm bombs and cluster bombs on
innocent civilians. After all, according to your flawed logic, taking out
entire villages with several bombs isn't as bad as a quick beheading with a
knife. You Mr Sina, need to get your priorities straight, and you need to
recognize WHO it is that is the threat to world peace and prosperity. You speak
out against suicide bombs and executions which occur rarely in the Islamic
world, yet you turn a blind eye against what goes on in your backyard. Why
don't you speak out against the gangs of Los Angeles
and Detroit? Why don't you speak out against the rising crime rates in Toronto
and Edmonton? Why don't you criticize the frequency of rape found in cities
such as Atlanta and Dallas? No, you have problems in your own backyard yet you
demand that Muslims stop the killing.
I suggest that you clean up your act before you come speak to us about our
behavior. And regarding the suicide bombings in Iraq, tell me which army is
stationed there? This was not a serious problem during the reign of Saddam
Hussein and this phenomenon began in 2003. And blowing up a marketplace has
nothing to do with the teachings of Islam. Recently a bomb exploded in a mosque
in Iraq, killing dozens of civilians. Now tell me: WHAT KIND OF MUSLIM WOULD
BLOW UP A MOSQUE? It is obvious that these actions have nothing to do with
Islam whatsoever and have no basis in our religion. You claim incidents such as
these show the true face of Islam yet you do not bring any evidence from the
Islamic scriptures which back up your claim. All you manage to do is bring
verses from the Quran out of context and claim that it advocates this and that.
Well in case you do not know Mr Sina, vigilantism is forbidden in Islam and it
was never practiced by the Islamic
community, laying to rest your claims that such incidents as the murder of
Aqsa Parvez show the true face of Islam.
According to you, having a society filled with hoodlums blowing up mosques and
shooting random people is what Islam projects a society to be like, showing how
vastly ignorant you are of Islam. You are intentionally lying and misleading
thousands of otherwise neutral Non-Muslims away from the truth of Islam, and I
can't understand what goes on through your mind when you do such a thing. We
are 1.5 billion strong Mr Sina, and Islam isn't going anywhere. However hard
you wish, you will never be able to eradicate Islam, and insulting Islam from
behind your keyboard really won't make a significant amount of Muslims leave
Islam. There is a saying, "Every hour a true sucker is born."
It truly amazes me how naive you are Mr Sina, as if "proving" that a 7th
century man was a criminal really is going to solve the problem of world peace.
You act as if the majority of the Muslims aren't aware of what is written in
the Islamic scriptures, proving how naive and arrogant you are. We do know of
the stories of the Banu Qurayza, the Jews of Khaybar, and the marriage of
Aisha, but we do not take such incidents as a first priority and we definitely
do not allow these incidents to define our religion as a whole. You blatantly
misunderstand Islam and pick and choose pieces of the religion which you like,
disregarding writings which do not agree with what you believe. You know,
people as ignorant and naive as you come along once in a century Mr Sina, and I
really do enjoy laughing at how you embarrass yourself here as nothing more
than a weirdo.
Al-Ansar
----------------------------
"People who worry that nuclear weaponry will one day fall in the hands of the
Arabs, fail to realize that the Islamic bomb has been dropped already, it fell
the day Muhammad was born." -- Dr. Joseph Adam Pearson
