On Jun 14, 2010, at 5:35 PM, Carl Steinbach wrote: Hi John,
You mentioned to me offline last week about using Review Board for collaborative review of Hive issues, and I noticed that you started with one issue already (http://review.hbase.org/r/178/). Once we've made sure it's working smoothly, it would be cool if everyone we can get everyone using this for uniformity. Right, I was just testing this out to see if it works. I probably should have sent a note out to the hive-dev list first. OK, I just used it for one also so I could test it out. Worked fine for me. I asked Todd Lipcon about this and he said that he can probably set up a vhost for Hive, but that will require an address, and it probably won't work seamlessly, e.g. emails will likely still refer to hbase.org<http://hbase.org>. He suggested instead that we rename the server review.cloudera.com<http://review.cloudera.com> (which I don't think folks will like), or hadoopreview.org<http://hadoopreview.org> (which won't cover TLPs), or apachereview.org<http://apachereview.org> (which will probably cause problems with the ASF). Do you have any ideas how to solve this problem? Also, is there any chance that Facebook can host this server? We're currently hosting it as an EC2 instance which is kind of expensive. I'm checking with Jonathan Gray to see if we can provide hosting for this (and what the best way to name it would be, since there may be some other projects like thrift and scribe that want it to). Sounds good to me. Should I got ahead and document it now or wait until we get the domain name issue resolved? Add a section with a note saying that this is currently only a proposal, and then we can remove the note once everything is settled. JVS
