Assalamu'alaikum netters budiman.....
Ni saya forwardkan artikel yg dihantar ke Muslimat Net berkenaan dengan jawapan kepada Fatimah.
Sesiapa yg nak tambah, silakanlah....
Wassalam
===========================================================================
Sent by a Muslimat's netter:
asm,
I sent fatimah's article to my husband and here is his
reply. i really hope, this reply would eventually
finds its way to this very confused fatimah of kelana
jaya.
> I read this from malaysiakini several days ago,
> malas nak layan actually.
> Foremost, this 'Fatimah Kelana Jaya' is jahil to the
> highest standard by
> equating her religion Islam (I presume) with other
> religions. Secondly her
> arguments against PAS and (indirectly) Islam are
> mostly unsubstantiated and
> lame even though the English is okay. Maybe she
> comes from a writer
> background but not a solid religious background.
>
>
> 1. 'Fatimah' is ASSUMING her Chinese sister-in-law
> will be divorced and
> after that will go back to her old religion bcoz her
> Muslim husband is bad.
> So she is implying her friend became a muslim for
> marriage only. Instead of
> trying to convince her friend to become better
> muslimat even in the event of
> divorce, she is like encouraging her to quit Islam
> upon divorce. It may be a
> mistake for that Chinese woman to marry the brother,
> but she should tell her
> it is not a mistake to become a muslim. But if the
> Chinese sister-in-law
> thinks it is also a mistake in becoming a muslim,
> she has to take
> responsibility for her 'mistake' .
>
> If I am a certified engineer, I am responsible to be
> prosecuted under the
> country's law if something happens due to my design
> mistake. Same thing
> here.
>
> 2. Who said PAS follows Pakistan? I think this
> 'Fatimah' tembak aje and
> confused. In hudud there are procedures for ACCUSING
> someone of zina. If a
> person is raped, she doesn't have to produce
> witnesses but if she is
> suspected of lying and committing zina, the onus is
> on the ACCUSER to
> produce witnesses. With modern technology, the
> culprit can be traced, either
> from the DNA or positive identification by the
> victim. Then the normal
> course of investigation and law will take place. So,
> whoever is lying or
> making fitnah people will know sooner or later.
>
> 3. The Qoran speaks of hudud law by mentioning its
> principles. Hudud law's
> details are up to the interpretation of the syariah
> authorities. If she is
> an authority in Islamic law, 'Fatimah' is welcome to
> give her input. But to
> condemn against the hudud law without authority, is
> like a villager who
> never goes to US and yet condemning the constitution
> of US.
>
> 4--onwards, this 'Fatimah' is losing her head
> totally, accusing PAS of being
> anti-women and anti-development without producing an
> iota of evidence, like
> PAS treats women as sex object (4), PAS is the
> orthodox who thinks a husband
> has the right to beat her wife (5), PAS discriminate
> against women (6), PAS
> is against all forms of entertainment (7&8), PAS
> beat women who do not wear
> tudung (9), PAS is actually against democracy and
> will eliminate partners in
> BA (10), PAS is against Malays being progressive
> (11), PAS is going to
> segregate and destabilise this country (12) etc. No
> point continuing if in
> the first place she is making plenty of wrong
> assumptions against PAS.
>
> If Malaysia is the only place to live for 'Fatimah
> Kelana Jaya', it is also
> true for PAS supporters. Let the only place we know
> be the best place for
> our family and future generations -- no drugs, no
> vices, no crimes, no high
> taxes, good education, high moral values, high
> self-esteem, balanced life
> for every individual. If you listen to PAS closely,
> that is what it is
> preaching all this while, and that is what it is
> practising, starting with
> its leaders like Fadzil Nor, Hadi Awang and Nik
> Aziz. See for yourselves.
>
> Compare to one Malay-based party who happens to be
> ruling this country. They
> talked as if they are concerned, but the moment they
> leave the rostrum and
> out of camera's focus, their world changes upside
> down. Cakap tak serupa
> bikin.
