*~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*
 {  Sila lawat Laman Hizbi-Net -  http://www.hizbi.net     }
 {        Hantarkan mesej anda ke:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]         }
 {        Iklan barangan? Hantarkan ke [EMAIL PROTECTED]     }
 *~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*
          PAS : KE ARAH PEMERINTAHAN ISLAM YANG ADIL
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
How can the US bomb this tragic people?

By Robert Fisk
The Independent, UK - Sept 23

http://www.independent.co.uk/story.jsp?story=95487

We are witnessing this weekend one of the most epic events since 
the Second World War, certainly since Vietnam. I am not talking 
about the ruins of the World Trade Centre in New York and the 
grotesque physical scenes which we watched on 11 September, an 
atrocity which I described last week as a crime against humanity 
(of which more later). No, I am referring to the extraordinary, 
almost unbelievable preparations now under way for the most 
powerful nation ever to have existed on God's Earth to bomb the 
most devastated, ravaged, starvation-haunted and tragic country 
in the world. Afghanistan, raped and eviscerated by the Russian 
army for 10 years, abandoned by its friends - us, of course - 
once the Russians had fled, is about to be attacked by the 
surviving superpower.

I watch these events with incredulity, not least because I was a 
witness to the Russian invasion and occupation. How they fought 
for us, those Afghans, how they believed our word. How they trusted 
President Carter when he  promised the West's support. I even met 
the CIA spook in Peshawar, brandishing the identity papers of a 
Soviet pilot, shot down with one of our missiles - which had been 
scooped from the wreckage of his Mig. "Poor guy," the CIA man said, 
before showing us a movie about GIs zapping the Vietcong in his 
private cinema. And yes, I remember what the Soviet officers told 
me after arresting me at Salang. They were performing their
international duty in Afghanistan, they told me. They were 
"punishing the terrorists" who wished to overthrow the (communist) 
Afghan government and destroy its people. Sound familiar?

I was working for The Times in 1980, and just south of Kabul I 
picked up a  very disturbing story. A group of religious mujahedin 
fighters had attacked a school because the communist regime had 
forced girls to be educated alongside boys. So they had bombed the 
school, murdered the head teacher's wife and cut off her husband's 
head. It was all true. But when The Times ran the story, the Foreign 
Office complained to the foreign desk that my report gave support to 
the Russians. Of course. Because the Afghan fighters were the good 
guys. Because Osama bin Laden was a good guy. Charles Douglas-Home, 
then editor of The Times would always insist that Afghan guerrillas 
were called "freedom fighters" in the headline. There was nothing 
you couldn't do with words.

And so it is today. President Bush now threatens the obscurantist,
ignorant, super-conservative Taliban with the same punishment as 
he intends to mete out to bin Laden. Bush originally talked about 
"justice and punishment" and about "bringing to justice" the 
perpetrators of the atrocities. But he's not sending policemen to 
the Middle East; he's sending B-52s. And F-16s and AWACS planes and 
Apache helicopters. We are not going to arrest bin Laden. We are 
going to destroy him. And that's fine if he's the guilty man. But 
B-52s don't discriminate between men wearing turbans, or between 
men and women or women and children.

I wrote last week about the culture of censorship which is now to 
smother us, and of the personal attacks which any journalist 
questioning the roots of this crisis endures. Last week, in a 
national European newspaper, I got a new and revealing example of 
what this means. I was accused of being anti-American and then 
informed that anti-Americanism was akin to anti-Semitism. You get 
the point, of course. I'm not really sure what anti-Americanism is. 
But criticising the United States is now to be the moral equivalent 
of Jew-hating. It's OK to write headlines about "Islamic terror" or 
my favourite French example "God's madmen", but it's definitely out 
of bounds to ask why the United States is loathed by so many Arab
Muslims in the Middle East. We can give the murderers a Muslim 
identity: we can finger the Middle East for the crime - but we may 
not suggest any reasons for the crime.

But let's go back to that word justice. Re-watching that pornography 
of mass-murder in New York, there must be many people who share my 
view that this was a crime against humanity. More than 6,000 dead; 
that's a Srebrenica of a slaughter. Even the Serbs spared most of 
the women and children when they killed their menfolk. The dead of 
Srebrenica deserve - and are getting - international justice at the 
Hague. So surely what we need is an International Criminal Court to 
deal with the sorts of killer who devastated New York on 11 September. 
Yet "crime against humanity" is not a phrase we are hearing from the 
Americans. They prefer "terrorist atrocity", which is slightly less 
powerful. Why, I wonder? Because to speak of a terrorist crime 
against humanity would be a tautology. Or because the US is against 
international justice. Or because it specifically opposed the creation 
of an international court on the grounds that its own citizens may
one day be arraigned in front of it.

The problem is that America wants its own version of justice, a 
concept rooted, it seems, in the Wild West and Hollywood's version 
of the Second World War. President Bush speaks of smoking them out, 
of the old posters that once graced Dodge City: "Wanted, Dead or 
Alive". Tony Blair now tells us that we must stand by America as 
America stood by us in the Second World War. Yes, it's true that 
America helped us liberate Western Europe. But in both world wars, 
the US chose to intervene after only a long and - in the case of 
the Second World War - very profitable period of neutrality.


Don't the dead of Manhattan deserve better than this? It's less 
than three years since we launched a 200-Cruise missile attack on 
Iraq for throwing out the UN arms inspectors. Needless to say, 
nothing was achieved. More Iraqis were killed, and the UN inspectors 
never got back, and sanctions continued, and Iraqi children 
continued to die. No policy, no perspective. Action, not words.

And that's where we are today. Instead of helping Afghanistan, 
instead of pouring our aid into that country 10 years ago, 
rebuilding its cities and culture and creating a new political 
centre that would go beyond tribalism, we left it to rot. Sarajevo 
would be rebuilt. Not Kabul. Democracy, of a kind, could be set up 
in Bosnia. Not in Afghanistan. Schools could be reopened in Tuzla 
and Travnik. Not in Jaladabad. When the Taliban arrived, stringing 
up every opponent, chopping off the arms of thieves, stoning women 
for adultery, the United States regarded this dreadful outfit as a
force for stability after the years of anarchy.

Bush's threats have effectively forced the evacuation of every 
Western aid worker. Already, Afghans are dying because of their 
absence. Drought and starvation go on killing millions - I mean 
millions - and between 20 and 25 Afghans are blown up every day 
by the 10 million mines the Russians left behind. Of course, the 
Russians never went back to clear the mines. I suppose those B-52 
bombs will explode a few of them. But that'll be the only 
humanitarian work we're likely to see in the near future.

Look at the most startling image of all this past week. Pakistan 
has closed its border with Afghanistan. So has Iran. The Afghans 
are to stay in their prison. Unless they make it through Pakistan 
and wash up on the beaches of France or the waters of Australia 
or climb through the Channel Tunnel or hijack a plane to Britain 
to face the wrath of our Home Secretary. In which case, they must 
be sent back, returned, refused entry. It's a truly terrible irony 
that the only man we would be interested in receiving from Afghanistan 
is the man we are told is the evil genius behind the greatest mass-
murder in American history: bin Laden. The others can stay at home 
and die.

 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
 ( Melanggan ? To : [EMAIL PROTECTED]   pada body : SUBSCRIBE HIZB)
 ( Berhenti ? To : [EMAIL PROTECTED]  pada body:  UNSUBSCRIBE HIZB)
 ( Segala pendapat yang dikemukakan tidak menggambarkan             )
 ( pandangan rasmi & bukan tanggungjawab HIZBI-Net                  )
 ( Bermasalah? Sila hubungi [EMAIL PROTECTED]                    )
 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Pengirim: MrChan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Kirim email ke