David Kraeutmann wrote:
> LGPL is useless for standalone apps. BSD-style licenses are good tho'.
>   
That is not true. What if I wanted to copy code from my GPL'd program to 
my LGPL library and the code is commited by others?

If I released my Maxsi Compile tool under the GNU LGPLv3, then you are 
allowed to copy its code to GNU LGPLv3 libraries. This would not be 
permitted if I released it under GNU GPLv3. All my programs are 
currently under GNU LGPLv3 (because of licensing issues with 
implementing them in Source, just to be safe) and I frequently move code 
between the actual .exe files and my shared library Maxsi Engine. I 
would not be able to do that with code commited by others if I released 
it under GNU GPLv3 - so that's a bit of a problem. If I am wrong about 
any of this, feel free to correct me with properly sourced material.

Whether to use GPL or LGPL is a matter of strategy and I am leaning 
towards GPL here.

_______________________________________________
To unsubscribe, edit your list preferences, or view the list archives, please 
visit:
http://list.valvesoftware.com/mailman/listinfo/hlcoders

Reply via email to