>>>>> "Curtis" == Curtis Villamizar <[email protected]> writes:
    Curtis> The issue is what happens when *my* fridge is not on the same home
    Curtis> subnet as *my* home computer.  (Sustituting a more realistic 
example,
    Curtis> like thermostats, water heater, alarm system, etc, where temp/time
    Curtis> profiles might be altered, but we'll stick with the fridge
    Curtis> example).

this is an issue, and we have some proposals to solve this.

It's not the issue that I'm talking about.  I'm saying that I want to
leverage the sitelocal host discovery protocol to also discover a global
name for the host.  I'm suggeting that an application (e.g. browser,
cups, etc.) on a mobile device should never (by default) actually
bookmark "fridge.local", because it's not globally meaningful.

    Curtis> A separate issue is how to address the fridge from a computer at 
work
    Curtis> or a mobile phone where clearly neither are on the same site.  Here 
a
    Curtis> domain name has to be assigned and most likely something of the form
    Curtis> <subdomain>.<provider-fqdn> if there is not going to be a 
registration
    Curtis> fee.  The subdomain might be the same as the email address provided 
by
    Curtis> most home providers or <email>.site.<provider-fqdn>.  At worst the
    Curtis> mobile phone would need to have <email>.site.<provider-fqdn> in the
    Curtis> DNS search path so "fridge" can be resolved.

    Curtis> The sitelocal name then only serves a purpose when the site is not
    Curtis> connected to the provider and doesn't know its domain name.

It's not a hard problem, technically (layer 1-7)
It's a hard layer 8/9 problem, and I'm suggesting that maybe we need to
think about whether there are layer-5/6/7 things that we can do as we
are specifying the sitelocal discovery process to ease the layer 8/9
problem.


-- 
Michael Richardson <[email protected]>, Sandelman Software Works 

Attachment: pgpep1mIIPkH8.pgp
Description: PGP signature

_______________________________________________
homenet mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/homenet

Reply via email to