Hi Hornlisters, Just back from retrieving some belongings from the Gulf and am amazed at this current topic. I have RSI using the delete key.
I took delivery of my first 8D in the late 60's after it had languished in a New York warehouse for 6 months because of the dock strike. No problem there and nor with intonation when it finally arrived. In those days my father had a stroboscope at work and a beautiful box of chromatic tuning forks - still in my possession. I never used either to tune my horn. Tune the 'G' second line treble clef on the F side, to a piano or Korg, and go from there. Decide which notes you are to play on which side of the instrument and I advise Farkas's system of F side below this 'G' and Bb side above. This is your template, the frame upon which you work. Then, remember the following: No horn is perfectly in tune within itself. No harmonic series is perfectly in tune even putting aside the 'rogue' notes. Even if the above were not true, it's all academic anyway because you have to play with other hornists and other instruments. If you are a second (or fourth) horn, your tuning is dictated by the player on your left - even to the extent of deciding to change an accepted fingering to compensate for the idiosyncrasies of others. I've played second to some great players and sometimes their fingering dictates a change in mine to accommodate their intonation. The lack of an independent Bb slide is of no consequence. I've always played 8Ds but a brief flirtation with Holton H179s convinced me the 8D's tuning was superior - if you know what you are doing and have an ear! Hans is right that empirical experience is better than theoretical, although the latter reads well on the Hornlist if you have the time and patience. However, he is wrong (and dare I say, a little disingenuous) when he criticises the Tylsar brothers. Apart from their recorded legacy where their intonation is open to scrutiny by all, a vibrato wave form can be either flat or sharp if only the highest or lowest point of the wave meets the line of true intonation. Nor do Czech players only play with vibrato; when they play straight, according to Hans's statement that vibrato disguises poor intonation, they would always play out of tune. I have seen and heard Zdenek Tylsar many times and I dispute that he played with all the slides in. However, I take Hans's point that no player should be playing with the slides thus. What worries me is the advertising features showing a famous player (not just horn players) lending his/her name to a product and nine times out of ten all the slides are in as far as they will go. And, naturally, I won't name the famous who do play in this mode! Finally, all horn players have an 'aid to tuning' ace up their sleeves - it's called a right hand! Use it! I'm afraid many, including some famous names, do not. Look at the Bernstein Mahler cycle on DVD with the Vienna Phil. and you will see Berger et al with hands not only moving across and back but sometimes in and out of the bell. Ralph R. Hall (brasshausmusic.com) _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
