William wrote: You're doing something if you're 'making it not flat'. Yes I am, but remember the rules were: not changing the dimension or length of the tube, not changing hand position, not lipping, not pulling slides, not changing the temperature, or anything else you can think of. My only point is that the horn doesn't have to follow the theoretical rules, because according to the rules, it shouldn't be possible to affect the pitch by following MY rules as quoted above. But it can be done, so blanket statements about certain partials always being in a certain place can't hold water. The real system that is a horn is much more complex than that, and there isn't any published information that can explain it. The acousticians don't understand it, so they've ignored it so far. I remember trying out an expensive custom horn a few years ago that had an incredibly flat top line F, but it made up for it by having an incredibly sharp G right above it. Now that was an interesting horn to try to play!
- Steve Mumford _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
