It was never my intent to stir up controversy - nor to be "sophomoric" or stubborn about any of my posts. I was merely trying to provide a more objective avenue of intonation using harmonics that normally should be in tune (and are normally manufactured to be in tune). Since my initial array of posts, I have been barraged by a lot of statements which I never implied or simply never said. I either must be poor at communication or it must be such a hot topic that it's easy to jump to conclusions about what someone else has stated.
I have never meant any of the following: * Horns are always perfectly in tune on every partial/harmonic * You should never listen and adjust when needed * You should never be aware of real life applications of theoretical models * You should never tune each side of the horn independently * You should expect partials to be perfect once you tune 8th partial * Hand position/lipping are unimportant when tuning * You should never tune the instrument before playing * You shouldn't be aware of other instruments around you I take the blame for being misunderstood - but it's also my duty to clear the air about my opinion since it appears to have been muddled. To clarify what I really meant: * Tune the 8th partial independently on both sides of the Horn (or all three) * Tune each valve's slide accordingly off of the 8th partial using 1 and 2 and 2,3 together * Expect certain harmonics on most horns to be flat/sharp (5th/6th) * My goal is to get each side of the horn is pretty well tuned to each other (perfect 4th apart) on 8th partial * I constantly use my ears, hands, etc. to tune notes when I have to - like when I'm on a naturally sharp harmonic, etc. * I end up knowing the harmonics of my horn and the natural tendencies of them (and for most horns) - but that doesn't preclude knowing that I must use my ears to tune (I know there are always certain notes to adjust, and my goal is to minimize the number of them). * Yes there are other variables - but tuning isn't magic and it isn't a mystery. There are real fundamentals at work, and my aim is to understand them and use them to my advantage. I don't know what else to say - but I hope this clears the air a bit and at least finally clarifies my point of view. -William _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
