As far as "the boss's daughter" situation, this comes up in real life, and the only thing to do is move past it. Otherwise you are just wasting valuable energy. Sometimes "move past it" means getting another job, etc.; other times--and this sounds like one of them--for a variety of reasons, it means learning to put up with the circumstances because changing them is impractical.
IMNSHO, as a rule band horn parts, high or low, are pretty uninspired, uninspiring, and unidiomatically written. So I don't think it's worth getting your shorts in a bunch about which one you get stuck with playing. I would find them all equally demoralizing. Again, in the real world, you'll have to play parts that you find, shall we say, less than fulfilling. That's just part of the gig as an ensemble player. (The pedagogical "wisdom" of putting the putatively best player on first, etc., in an allegedly educational situation is a rant I'll spare you for this post.) More importantly, however, each part plays its role in any composition. The view that some part is unimportant is reminiscent of the joke, totally inappropriate for this forum, about which part of the body is the boss; but the moral is the same. There are (usually) four parts. You won't always be playing first; in fact, odds are good that most of the time you won't be playing first. You have to take the attitude that you'll play whatever part you're assigned as well as you can. I suppose this could be looked upon as a corrollary (sp?) to the saying "the best revenge is living well," particularly if you have the "first horn is best horn" mentality. Also, again IMHO, the best horn player alive today is a second horn player. (No, I'm not going to give a name.) If this person can't do it, whatever "it" is cannot be done on a French horn, in my opinion. So don't get the (wrong) idea that "second horn" is a synonym for "second class." Finally, scales. Anyone who's read my posts knows that scales and arpeggios are as close to a religion as I have. The way to learn to play them better is to practice playing them. But you knew that before you posted. How to practice them? In addition to the good advice you've already gotten, I suggest this. First, determine what the key signature is for each scale before you start to practice it. Trying to figure out whether D is natural, sharp, or flat while in the middle of playing an E-flat melodic minor scale is counter-productive. Second, set a metronome. Set it at a speed that allows you to play your worst, most awkward scale smoothly and accurately, but use this speed for all your scales. You want to start with smoothness and accuracy, not speed. You can build speed later if you are smooth and accurate; you cannot graft smoothness and accuracy on top of speed. Once everything is fluent and dead easy at this speed, move the metronome up a notch. (I'm dating myself here: I'm thinking of a mechanical metronome where each notch is about 5% faster than the preceding one. I don't mean to move in one beat per minute increments.) The goals here are to get the fingering patterns into your fingers so you don't have to think about them, your breath working so the scales are smooth, your chops working so you aren't using bad habits to get the notes, etc., etc. I always practiced my scales chromatically, moving up a half step at a time. Some people like to go around the circle of fifths. (Ask if you don't know what that is or how to determine a scale's key signature. It isn't a sin not to know; we are all ignorant in different ways.) IMHO, which you do doesn't matter. What matters is that you can play the scales. Scales and arpeggios will improve your playing more than any other single thing. They are the foundation of your technique, both in the sense of finger wiggling and in the sense of breathing & breath control, embouchure, range, sound, and so on. They will *greatly* enhance your abilities at sight reading and transposition. The overwhelming majority of the music you will play at any level, from rankest beginner to top five U.S. orchestra, consists of scales, arpeggios, or some combination of the two. So if you can play scales and arpeggios, you can play anything (albeit in some cases with a little woodshedding <g>). End of sermon. And to think I was planning this as an uncharacteristically (for me) short post. Oh, and I disagree that you have a "juvenile problem." I think you are very mature not only to be able to identify what's holding you back, but also for wanting to take the steps needed to correct the situation. HTH. Howard Sanner [email protected] _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
