William Foss wrote:
I just graduated with a BME I am in the process of submitting
applications for graduate schools and graduate assistantships
[...]
As a part of these applications, I have to submit
letters of recommendation. Thinking about these letters, I am not completely
sure what purpose they serve. [...]
Then I got to wondering: Is the letter itself not as important as the position
of the person who wrote it? For example, would letters coming from my horn
teacher and my orchestra director mean more than one from the manager of the
music store where I teach lessons? [...]
William,
I have some information on Reference Letters and
Letters of Recommendation on my website (rileyguide.com/refer.html), so I'll
suggest you take a
minute and look at some of the resources listed. Meanwhile,
I'll also answer your questions with this quote from my site and my own
experience of over 14 years working in academe.
"Graduate students and Post Docs will want to review the information on
Recommendations. These are formal letters usually written by your academic
advisor or, if you are lucky, a respected person in your field who is familiar
with you and your work. They are used to support an application for an academic
or research position, including continued study programs. Who writes these
letters is an important as your own credentials and his or her name behind
yours is a real boost to your potential. You often are usually not given a
opportunity to review these letters, nor should you ask to review them. They
are confidential and meant only for those reviewing your application."
So, yes, who writes your letters is as important as what those letters say.
Many of your professors will ask you to outline what you want them to say, and
they will use that information to create the letters themselves. These letters
will emphasize what you want to pursue in your advanced studies -- music ed,
music performance, etc. -- so be sure they will say what you want the entrance
committee for your master's program to know about you and to consider.
While a letter from the manager of the music store could be quite good, it will
only really promote your efforts if he/she is someone the committee will
recognize as a professional in the field in which you wish to enter.
Good luck, and be sure you target programs that really interest you.
Scattershot applications are not a good idea.
Margaret
Margaret F. Dikel
The Riley Guide
11218 Ashley Dr.
Rockville, MD 20852
301-881-0122
[email protected]
www.rileyguide.com
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org