Sorry to jump in here with an on-topic response....

For the last 4 years that I played my Schmid double, I tuned with the bottom 
part.  For me, it kept the horn's resonance a bit more focused, especially on 
the F side.  I'm not sure if it sounded much different 5 feet away, but it felt 
different and sounded different to my right ear.  The difference was subtle.

Looking at the horn, I suspect this is related to the fact that the upper 
slide is so much farther from any braces that connect it to other pipes.

As an aside, in 8 years of playing the Schmid, I never once tuned it to a 
different key.  This is largely because I didn't want to deal with re-tuning 
the whole thing, especially for just one piece.  If I had a week to focus on 
preparing and performing one piece where it would be clearly beneficial, I 
might have done it, but there always seemed to be too many other 
pieces/gigs/etc. that demanded attention and a horn tuned normally.

Michael

P.S. I sent this same message to the list over 24 hours ago, but it never 
showed up by email or in the archive.  I have server logs to prove that the 
memphis.edu server accepted it, so I don't know what happened.  I apologize if 
anyone ends up getting this twice.

On Friday 27 November 2009 02:27:18 pm Joshua Cheuvront wrote:
> Ok, so I must've been unclear and started yet another pissing contest. 
> Boring and useless.  No one cares.  Do it off-list. Schmid horns have a 2
> part main tuning slide.  There is an upper bit and a lower bit.  When you
> tune the horn in F, Schmid recommends that you use the upper bit.  I've
> heard some players prefer, however, to use the lower bit.  There is a
> difference in how the horn plays depending on which part of the slide you
> choose to move.  I've only begun experimenting, and was wondering what
> OTHER SCHMID PLAYERS prefer, and why. Josh
> P.S.  One time, at band camp, I played the entire solo repertoire for horn
> from memory at twice the recommended tempi as loud as possible tuned to
> A440.7734206 and it opened up a small black hole and I was transported to
> an alternate universe where I was the king of everything but then I used a
> non-standard fingering and was instantly transported back to my crappy
> apartment in Queens where I've been forced to listen to myself practice
> every day. *le sigh* _______________________________________________
> post: [email protected]
> unsubscribe or set options at
> https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/mhrivnak%40hrivnak
>.org

_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to