Hope you don't mind if i slice and dice.

On Jul 12, 2010, at 6:41 AM, [email protected] wrote:

> From: [email protected]
> Subject: Re: [Hornlist] About those brass playing robots....
> To: [email protected]
> Message-ID: <[email protected]>
> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
>
>
> I can't agree at all. Why? Because how do you teach something to  
> another that is somehow a religious or spiritual experience? How can  
> you possibly define it? How can you transfer something that is  
> undefinable? Defining it that way is about as useful as glow in the  
> dark sunglasses.

Here we have two similes that make no sense, so this argument is false  
right away. No one is talking about a zero sum game between science  
and spirituality. You are setting this up as a straw man. So, let us  
move on. But wait! later we will need the part of "how can you  
define," etc.. It is also troubling to see that you have no idea of  
how to explain to someone something that is a spiritual or religious  
experience? Now i am just starting to feel sorry for you.
>
>
> If we were discussing Biology or Physics or a real science (even in  
> terms of pedagogy) this would be simply inexcusable. It would be  
> about the same level of precision as astrology or psychic powers.  
> But, there's no reason why we can't treat Horn playing and Music as  
> a real science. It exists in the real world. It is quantifiable. The  
> better we understand it, the better it will become.

Parts of horn playing are science, other parts aren't, they are more  
artistic. As someone who has spent most of his life cleaning up  
pedagogy, I do not buy your logic, again. You seem to want to stray  
from the point. You want to make music a science, so you argue from  
that point of view. Other people here are not taking that view, but  
you insist upon it anyway. There is a difference between science and  
art, and not everything in life is just one thing or another.
>
> Nevertheless, in medicine and psychology, things like emotion are  
> quantified and measureable. They exist in the real world. They  
> aren't supernatural. Our emotions are not some magic pixie dust.  
> They are products of our brains. They can be measured in an MRI.

Emotions are not measurable by an MRI or anything else. They are  
certainly not quantifiable in the absolute sense. They can be measured  
in different amounts by different tests, but you are WAY off here. No  
one has taken the view that they are pixie dust, either. Why do you  
exaggerate so to make your points? if you want us to consider you as a  
scientist, you should state your arguments scientifically.
>
> If you are able to define musicality you are able to better  
> understand it's effects on human emotion. You are better able to  
> teach it. Someone who can't even define it and resorts to mysticism  
> is someone to me who either really doesn't know what it is (is  
> living by intuition) or is unable to even figure out what he himself  
> is doing.

Expression is the product of careful calculation, as Tabuteau has  
said, but if you think that means you can somehow come up with some  
scientific formula for it, you are just wrong. Yes, there are a lot of  
things about musical expression that are written in the music and  
given by the conductor and come from our study. I am writing a book  
about this right now. To me, and i hope you take this without to great  
a degree of offense, you come off as a stat freak. You are not alone.  
A lot of the IT crowd today think everything can be translated into  
computer code. As others have stated, before it was science that would  
explain everything. I love science, but there are other things in life.
The thing is, even if everything were 'explained,' which i would  
welcome, then you and your ilk will still be really disappointed  
because you will still have to live life on a day to day basis with a  
bunch of human beings, who, even though their actions can be  
explained, may just do something that can't be predicted. Think humor...
>
> Saying something is religious or spiritual is saying that it isn't  
> understandable. Why bother learning anything about it at all if you  
> have that attitude that it is unknowable anyway?

Why all the either or arguments. Why set up everything you say with a  
premise that is either not true or changes the argument? Why do you  
constantly do this? I don't think anyone here is arguing what you say.  
But you have done this before.

>
> -William


Sorry for the long post, which has, as before, devolved into a study  
in semantics and lack of logic.
I do believe that we live in a time that has spawned a certain culture  
of rationalism that is just as flaky as their 'spiritual' enemies.  
These are people who think you can describe a basketball game using  
statistics. I am on a blog where people do that all the time. They  
don't even watch the games. This is madness. I am also on a  
photography blog where trees have been defined as chaos as opposed to  
brick walls, and photographers such as Galen Rowell and Ansel Adams  
are criticized for not having 'perfect' technique.'  Photos can now be  
described in minute terms using numbers! Pixels, colors, levels of  
dynamic range, distortion- all the things that make up 'art' have  
numerical values for explaining expression. It is also an epic fail.  
Not because they haven't come up with a description that fulfills  
their criteria, but because they are not even paying attention to what  
is the real point. The reason people like art.

The fact is, I was taught expression from a very young age. Not by  
numbers or MRIs, though. And yes, i can teach it to others, but they  
will have to find that part of themselves that doesn't show up on an  
MRI to activate it fully. There are elements in music that activate  
our emotions and if you programmed the robots just right, you could  
push a few emotional buttons, no doubt. The thing is, as human beings,  
we do sense when someone else or some group of people like an  
orchestra is reaching down in their own psyche(s) to transit their  
feeling to us. It is not voodoo or fairy dust. It just happens to be  
something we are wired to do. We can tell. We get it, maybe you don't.  
Deal with it.

Sincerely,
Wendell
For info about my book, DVDs, and live video chat horn lessons, see my  
web site at www.wendellworld.com







_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at 
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org

Reply via email to