With all the talk about robots, I was surprised that someone else didn't post
this NY Times article first:
July 9, 2010
Gee, Officer Krupke, I Need Those Violins
By PAUL WOODIEL
IN 1983, as a young violinist, I had the rare luck to form a friendship with
Leonard Bernstein. One summer evening the following year, during dinner,
Bernstein uttered a sentence that changed my life, “Why don’t you play ‘West
Side Story’ with me? I’m recording it in the fall.” I placed my soup spoon down
carefully, for as you may imagine, he had secured my full attention at that
particular moment.
Three months later, I found myself in the legendary (now long-defunct) RCA
Studio A in Midtown, in a state of sheer terror. I spent a week nestled in
Lenny’s orchestra, recording the full score of “West Side Story.” It was the
most exhilarating experience of my young life.
In the 25 years since, I have been fortunate enough to have had a rich and
varied career as a theater musician. I’ve toured the world as the fiddle on the
proverbial roof, sweltered in a marching band uniform in “The Music Man” and
played a languid tango in Norma Desmond’s mansion on Sunset Boulevard. Last
year, the stars aligned, allowing me to perform “West Side Story” again, this
time at the Palace Theater on Broadway.
Now, after 500 performances, our producers have told us and our union that in
order to cut costs they will chop our string section in half, releasing five
musicians and “replacing” them with a synthesizer piped in from another room. I
don’t think Lenny would have approved.
The sweeping grandeur of Broadway’s classic scores would be impossible without
master orchestrations. I would argue that the orchestrator’s crafty magic is
perhaps best appreciated from the pit below the stage — by musicians who thrill
(or despair, as the case may well be) to a given score night after night. To my
ear, the orchestration of “West Side Story” towers above all others, a
masterwork of complexity and beauty that still reveals marvels to my colleagues
and me.
The score’s eye-popping instrumental forces, too long to list here, involve
everything from bass saxophone to slide whistle to three piccolos. Bernstein
crafted 11 independent string parts to render his sublime love songs: “Maria,”
“Tonight,” “Somewhere” and “One Hand, One Heart.”
Soon, though, if all goes according to plan, these songs will be produced by a
skeletal string section accompanied by an inert, artificial, electronic device,
which an engineer will try to manipulate, hoping to deceive audiences into
thinking it’s the real thing. (I must note that I will still be there, lest
this sound merely self-serving.) The producers are doubtless betting audiences
won’t notice the difference. But if you happen to be listening, as Lenny would
have suggested you do, you will notice.
Things aren’t great for Broadway musicians. There are fewer jobs than ever, as
orchestras have increasingly become small bands. I’m O.K. with that; times
change. Some shows need orchestras and violins; others don’t.
But “West Side Story” is one of those shows that does. The show is inseparable
from its lush, sophisticated orchestration. So here’s my proposition: if the
show is no longer profitable, the producers should simply close it with its
dignity intact. Doing so might put me out of work, but it would honor (rather
than demean) the legacy of Bernstein’s crown jewel.
Paul Woodiel is a violinist.
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org