Great explanation!One more thing to ad is the feeling that ESRI is counting with oSM and the feeling that many things Are changing in emergencies: croud or community Are on the grid for humanitarian action more than ever!
Enviat desde l'ipod de la Eva i en Robs. El 11/04/2012, a les 20:38, [email protected] va escriure: > Send HOT mailing list submissions to > [email protected] > > To subscribe or unsubscribe via the World Wide Web, visit > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot > or, via email, send a message with subject or body 'help' to > [email protected] > > You can reach the person managing the list at > [email protected] > > When replying, please edit your Subject line so it is more specific > than "Re: Contents of HOT digest..." > > > Today's Topics: > > 1. Feedback from the Red Cross, UN people, and Esri: YOU (OSM) > are GREAT!!! (Jean-Guilhem Cailton) > 2. Activation working group (tim) > 3. Re: Mali follow-up: OrbView-3 images of Anefis, > And?ramboukane and Aguelhok available (Jean-Guilhem Cailton) > 4. Re: Feedback from the Red Cross, UN people, and Esri: YOU > (OSM) are GREAT!!! (Mikel Maron) > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > > Message: 1 > Date: Wed, 11 Apr 2012 17:47:12 +0200 > From: Jean-Guilhem Cailton <[email protected]> > To: [email protected] > Cc: OSM-talk <[email protected]> > Subject: [HOT] Feedback from the Red Cross, UN people, and Esri: YOU > (OSM) are GREAT!!! > Message-ID: <[email protected]> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" > > Hi, > > Last week, I was at the conference "GIS for the United Nations and the > International Community", a conference organized by UNITAR's Operational > Satellite Application Programme (UNOSAT) and Esri, April 3-5, 2012, at > the World Meteorological Organization, in Geneva, Switzerland. > > The main message I'd like to get back to each and everyone of you, from > the almost unanimous feedback I received and witnessed while I was > there, is that OpenStreetMap is rather well known and very much > appreciated among the people who attended the conference. It is > difficult to carry across the kind of recognition and gratefulness that > I felt for the work of OSM volunteers, and no expression can be > exaggerated to convey it. I am not saying that Ban Ki-moon knows about > OSM as much as he probably knows about Google, for instance, but at > least the UN people connected in some (possibly remote) way to GIS know > about it, and some are really well aware of the strengths (and also of > course of the weaknesses) of OSM. > > Even in the panel that I attended in the first panel session, > "Geographic Information in Postcrisis - Transition to Stability and > Redevelopment", where OSM was not explicitly on the agenda, it came up > in the knowledgeable and lively discussion that followed, with some > strong opinions expressed about the "commercial" character of the > licence (from the point of view of this mostly humanitarian audience), > and the restrictions it implies, a topic that deserves more development > and to which I'll come back later in another post. > > The next day, I was a panelist in "Open Data and the Crowd: > Collaborating for Action", a panel moderated by Ryan Lanclos, Esri, > where I had been invited at the last minute to represent H.O.T. It was a > really very interesting panel, with Lars Bromley, UNITAR/UNOSAT, Jihad > Abdalla, Emergency Officer at UNICEF/EMOPS, Andrej Verity, UNOCHA, and > Fr?d?ric Zanetta, IFRC. UNOSAT had made their own experiments about > crowd-sourcing, and were well aware of its difficulties. I presented OSM > in general, and in particular the remote mobilization for Haiti (with an > extract of Tim Berners-Lee video at TED 2010) followed by field projects > there, with the example of the STM_020 project in Saint Marc, Haiti, > where I had just spent a month (I'll also come back to this later). I > think, judging from later interventions, that I managed to get across > the message that OSM is first of all a community (rather than a > "crowd"). A similar point was also later expressed from the audience, > with someone saying that organizations should "engage" with the "crowd", > not "use" it. In his conclusion, Andrej Verity encouraged the audience > "not to be afraid" to engage "the crowd". > After this panel, my personal feeling was an exhilarating one that > apparently everyone, from the panel and the interventions from the > audience, had a desire to move forward, iteratively improving > cooperation processes, and solving problems as they might arise. > > In the next panel that I attended, of particular interest was the > presentation by Ren? Saameli, of the ICRC, of the mapping of Walikale, > DR Congo, to support the Red Cross water supply project there, jointly > by remote OSM volunteers, who digitized the satellite image acquired by > the Red Cross, by local Red Cross representative and correspondents, who > collected field information, like names of streets and suburbs or points > of interest, on Walking Papers (with no need for GPS units - which would > be too costly if this process is to be repeated on a large scale), and > remote OSM volunteers again, who entered WP info into the database, to > produce a complete and accurate map of the town. Analyzes, such as > population repartition estimation based on digitized buildings, could > then also be conducted. The ICRC was so pleased by this project, as well > as previous joint work with OSM (like for mapping Osh in Kirghiztan > during the 2010 troubles there) that he declared that they are preparing > a Memorandum of Understanding with HOT, and envision the possibility to > have volunteers who would be both "Red Cross" and "HOT", as the Red > Cross and OSM are both mainly volunteers movements. Big credit goes to > Fr?d?ric Bonifas for building this trust relationship over the years. > Here is an interview about this collaborative mapping: > http://www.icrc.org/eng/resources/documents/interview/2012/mapping-interview-2012-04-05.htm > Getting closer to the Red Cross and its millions of volunteers > worldwide, for those interested, could be a way to bridge the missing > link between the potential of OSM tools and the (mostly unmapped and > unconnected) local communities of the developing world, where they could > be really useful to make a difference. > And this could also be a popularity boost for OSM, by making lay people > aware of the link between maps and humanitarian action. > Like Ren? said off the record, it could be a reply from "humanitarians > with boots on the ground" to the World Bank/Google agreement that made > some noise earlier this year. > > The closing session offered summaries of the panels that had taken place > in parallel. A summary of the summaries was: "Free the data!" (instead > of keeping it in silos where it is difficult for others to access and use). > > One of the visions that Jack Dangermond, founder and president of Esri, > shared, is that over more than 40 years in the field of GIS, he had > witnessed a few revolutionary technological changes: remote sensing, > GPS, and now, crowd-sourcing. > > The main points of Esri's presentations that might be of interest here are: > - the recently released version 2.0 of ArcGIS editor for OSM > (https://esriosmeditor.codeplex.com/), > - the general move towards "the cloud", with the ability to share > hundreds of thousands of maps online, even for those without their own > server, > - the possibility to easily create (point) map layers from spreadsheets > (containing geo-coordinates columns) ("as easy as drag and drop"), > - data collection tools on mobile devices (directly derived from data > models). > They also recalled that they have a program to supply software licenses > to nonprofit organizations, which could apply to HOT (at least). > > HXL (Humanitarian eXchange Language) is a draft standard, initiated by > OCHA, designed to address the problem that "information sharing is > becoming the bottleneck to efficient aid". > > This conference allowed me to meet people from the Red Cross, MapAction, > UN-OCHA, USAID/OTI, ACTED,... and GIS and information officers from > South Sudan and Pakistan. By the way, who would like to help organize a > mapping party in Islamabad? > > I also had the pleasure to meet St?phane Henriod, who is interested in > natural disasters data and in contributing to OSM in Tajikistan, as you > may have seen on the HOT list, and Robert Colombo, who was "the guy in > the audience always asking many good, thought provoking, questions" (and > had activated SBTF, GisCorps and HOT to collect health facilities info > for Libya, from his position at WHO in Tunis). And it was, as always, a > pleasure to be able to chat with Fred Moine, who must now be back in > Haiti for IOM. Thanks to Mikel for introducing me to the panel > moderator, and to Nicolas for introducing me to his contacts who were > likely to be at the conference. > > But maybe the best surprise for me was an "African citizen" (who works > in the UN) who came to me after my presentation to tell me that he > thought that OSM could be a development and democratization tool that > African youths, who have for instance contributed to the recent > democratic change in Senegal, could use to organize themselves and to > manage their own communities. This matched perfectly the vision that we > had in Haiti with Nicolas... So let's make it happen! > > Best wishes, > > Jean-Guilhem > > > > > -------------- next part -------------- > An HTML attachment was scrubbed... > URL: > <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/hot/attachments/20120411/bc552108/attachment-0001.html> > > ------------------------------ > > Message: 2 > Date: Wed, 11 Apr 2012 13:29:23 -0400 > From: tim <[email protected]> > To: [email protected] > Subject: [HOT] Activation working group > Message-ID: > <cannyer37b9oapatq02mmiemarup1pslmjsfifunydntwcpe...@mail.gmail.com> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 > > Hoping to join the call tomorrow - but have not be able to connect the > last two times I tried to get onto the #hot IRC channel for calls. It > just hangs. > > Regardless here is some food for thought. > > 1. In our emergency response agency you could categorize our > activation / plan guidance into two groups: the first group guidance > is specifc to incidents of a certain type e.g. an earthquake > activation, a heat wave activation, a flood activation; the second > group is specific to operations / response needs e.g.debris clearance, > evacuation, food distribution - which could be triggered by a range of > different incidents and can be pulled off the shelf, mixed and matched > - a more modular approach. > > 2. You may have seen the message below from the crisis mappers list > already but thought I would attach it for anyone who didn't. > > Tim > > ---------- Forwarded message ---------- > From: John Crowley <[email protected]> > Date: Wed, Apr 11, 2012 at 12:15 PM > Subject: [CrisisMappers] Disaster Songbook: coordinating the crowd > To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]> > > Friends, > > As I awoke this morning to news that we might be replaying the Boxing > Day tsunami from 2004 all over again, I watched the actions across my > various email, skype, and twitter channels and got anxious. We have > made so much progress on technology and practice since 2004, and we > now have a community of dedicated and talented crisis mappers, and > yet, our coordination is still not where it could be. > > I realized that I had no ability to predict who was awake and who was > working which issue. Did we need imagery; which areas of interest > (AOIs) and when would the next potential satellite pass be? Did we > need maps; how current are those areas in either Google MapMaker or > OpenStreetMap? Did we have a method of pulling in social media and > making sense of it; or would we wait for activation? Yes, had the > emergency unfolded differently, we would have got to these questions > eventually, but wouldn't it be great if questions like these--or > perhaps better ones--were deeply ingrained in all our heads, like a > musician know his or her scales? > > For a while now, I have been thinking about bringing concepts from > jazz into humanitarian information management. As a classically > trained cellist, I had to relearn to think in this way, as my > experience has been very different. For thirty years, I was taught how > to realize "scores"--musical blueprints that specify in great detail > what each voice should be doing at any given moment in the music work. > That approach works when you have a full understanding of the universe > of possibilities--when the score is a completed architecture and just > needs to be "recreated." This is the approach of many disaster > management agencies. That said, with disasters, improvisation is > needed; we need to make the music as we go, and we cannot predict what > any given actor will need to do at any one time. > > That said, however 'unspecified and unscoped' the response operation > may become does not necessarily mean we as crisis mappers need to be > 'out of harmony or rhythm.' In jazz, there is a shared oral tradition > that everyone learns: a set of melodies, harmonies, and rhythms and a > morality around how to interact using those shared patterns in an > ensemble. Together, musicians with such a common understanding can > take even a fragment of a melody and create incredible structures that > they did not have planned out when they played the first note. What if > we had such a system for our crisis mapping work? What if we could > know who is doing what with which tool and community, and how it all > is weaving together into a (harmonious) whole, without over-specifying > who does what or recreating ossified bureaucracies that move slowly? > > Yes, we are making progress towards this end with shared protocols, > trainings, and experiments. But we need to bring those efforts > together again. We need to develop the ingrained, practical knowledge > sometimes called metis. > > I would like to advocate that we start work on such a song book, so > that the next major disaster, we all have a basic song list to play > off (with all the melodies, chords, and rhythms implied), and the > ability to predict what each other will be doing, even if only in > rough outlines. That way, we can improvise more effectively together. > > Who wants to jam? We need to build some riffs. > > John Crowley > > Research Fellow at the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative and > Lead for the Camp Roberts Experiments @ NDU/STAR-TIDES > > -- > You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google > Groups "CrisisMappers" group. > To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. > To unsubscribe from this group, send email to > [email protected]. > For more options, visit this group at > http://groups.google.com/group/crisismappers?hl=en. > > > > ------------------------------ > > Message: 3 > Date: Wed, 11 Apr 2012 21:26:23 +0200 > From: Jean-Guilhem Cailton <[email protected]> > To: Fr?d?ric Bonifas <[email protected]> > Cc: [email protected] > Subject: Re: [HOT] Mali follow-up: OrbView-3 images of Anefis, > And?ramboukane and Aguelhok available > Message-ID: <[email protected]> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 > > Hi, > > The OrbView-3 images for these three towns are now integrated in the > Tile Service at the same URL previously given > (i.e.: > for JOSM: > tms:http://osm.arkemie.org/cgi-bin/tiles/1.0.0/mali/{zoom}/{x}/{y} > and for Potlatch 2: > http://osm.arkemie.org/cgi-bin/tiles/1.0.0/mali/$z/$x/$y > ) > > Best wishes, > > Jean-Guilhem > > > Le 08/04/2012 13:56, Fr?d?ric Bonifas a ?crit : >> The google doc is already updated, and 3 Orbview3 images can be used >> for the cities of Anefis, And?ramboukane and Aguelhok : >> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AiGw62ddccqhdEZ4Vi1hVmRKNmVseHpFOWVrdWR2Nmc >> >> Best >> >> Fred >> >> Le 8 avril 2012 13:41, Fr?d?ric Bonifas <[email protected]> a ?crit : >>> Hi, >>> >>> I have updated the Mali wiki page to emphasize the need for imagery >>> and what can already be mapped : >>> http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/2012_Mali_Crisis#Things_to_do >>> >>> Best >>> >>> -- >>> Fr?d?ric Bonifas >>> +33672652807 skype:fredericbonifas >> >> > > > -- > gpg 0x5939EAE2 > > > > > ------------------------------ > > Message: 4 > Date: Wed, 11 Apr 2012 12:38:18 -0700 (PDT) > From: Mikel Maron <[email protected]> > To: Jean-Guilhem Cailton <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" > <[email protected]> > Cc: OSM-talk <[email protected]> > Subject: Re: [HOT] Feedback from the Red Cross, UN people, and Esri: > YOU (OSM) are GREAT!!! > Message-ID: > <[email protected]> > Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" > > thanks for the wonderful summary of the conference JGC, sounds like a great > success ... can we get this up on the HOT blog? > ? > * Mikel Maron *?+14152835207 @mikel s:mikelmaron > > >> ________________________________ >> From: Jean-Guilhem Cailton <[email protected]> >> To: [email protected] >> Cc: OSM-talk <[email protected]> >> Sent: Wednesday, April 11, 2012 4:47 PM >> Subject: [HOT] Feedback from the Red Cross, UN people, and Esri: YOU (OSM) >> are GREAT!!! >> >> >> Hi, >> >> Last week, I was at the conference "GIS for the United Nations and > the International Community", a conference organized by UNITAR's > Operational Satellite Application Programme (UNOSAT) and Esri, > April 3-5, 2012, at the World Meteorological Organization, in > Geneva, Switzerland. >> >> The main message I'd like to get back to each and everyone of you, > from the almost unanimous feedback I received and witnessed while > I was there, is that OpenStreetMap is rather well known and very > much appreciated among the people who attended the conference. It > is difficult to carry across the kind of recognition and > gratefulness that I felt for the work of OSM volunteers, and no > expression can be exaggerated to convey it. I am not saying that > Ban Ki-moon knows about OSM as much as he probably knows about > Google, for instance, but at least the UN people connected in some > (possibly remote) way to GIS know about it, and some are really > well aware of the strengths (and also of course of the weaknesses) > of OSM. >> >> Even in the panel that I attended in the first panel session, > "Geographic Information in Postcrisis - Transition to Stability > and Redevelopment", where OSM was not explicitly on the agenda, it > came up in the knowledgeable and lively discussion that followed, > with some strong opinions expressed about the "commercial" > character of the licence (from the point of view of this mostly > humanitarian audience), and the restrictions it implies, a topic > that deserves more development and to which I'll come back later > in another post. >> >> The next day, I was a panelist in "Open Data and the Crowd: > Collaborating for Action", a panel moderated by Ryan Lanclos, > Esri, where I had been invited at the last minute to represent > H.O.T. It was a really very interesting panel, with Lars Bromley, > UNITAR/UNOSAT, Jihad Abdalla, Emergency Officer at UNICEF/EMOPS, > Andrej Verity, UNOCHA, and Fr?d?ric Zanetta, IFRC. UNOSAT had made > their own experiments about crowd-sourcing, and were well aware of > its difficulties. I presented OSM in general, and in particular > the remote mobilization for Haiti (with an extract of Tim > Berners-Lee video at TED 2010) followed by field projects there, > with the example of the STM_020 project in Saint Marc, Haiti, > where I had just spent a month (I'll also come back to this > later). I think, judging from later interventions, that I managed > to get across the message that OSM is first of all a community > (rather than a "crowd"). A similar point was also later expressed > from the audience, with someone saying that organizations should > "engage" with the "crowd", not "use" it. In his conclusion, Andrej > Verity encouraged the audience "not to be afraid" to engage "the > crowd". >> After this panel, my personal feeling was an exhilarating one that > apparently everyone, from the panel and the interventions from the > audience, had a desire to move forward, iteratively improving > cooperation processes, and solving problems as they might arise. >> >> In the next panel that I attended, of particular interest was the > presentation by Ren? Saameli, of the ICRC, of the mapping of > Walikale, DR Congo, to support the Red Cross water supply project > there, jointly by remote OSM volunteers, who digitized the > satellite image acquired by the Red Cross, by local Red Cross > representative and correspondents, who collected field > information, like names of streets and suburbs or points of > interest, on Walking Papers (with no need for GPS units - which > would be too costly if this process is to be repeated on a large > scale), and remote OSM volunteers again, who entered WP info into > the database, to produce a complete and accurate map of the town. > Analyzes, such as population repartition estimation based on > digitized buildings, could then also be conducted. The ICRC was so > pleased by this project, as well as previous joint work with OSM > (like for mapping Osh in Kirghiztan during the 2010 troubles > there) that he declared that they are preparing a Memorandum of > Understanding with HOT, and envision the possibility to have > volunteers who would be both "Red Cross" and "HOT", as the Red > Cross and OSM are both mainly volunteers movements. Big credit > goes to Fr?d?ric Bonifas for building this trust relationship over > the years. >> Here is an interview about this collaborative mapping: >> http://www.icrc.org/eng/resources/documents/interview/2012/mapping-interview-2012-04-05.htm >> Getting closer to the Red Cross and its millions of volunteers > worldwide, for those interested, could be a way to bridge the > missing link between the potential of OSM tools and the (mostly > unmapped and unconnected) local communities of the developing > world, where they could be really useful to make a difference. >> And this could also be a popularity boost for OSM, by making lay > people aware of the link between maps and humanitarian action. >> Like Ren? said off the record, it could be a reply from > "humanitarians with boots on the ground" to the World Bank/Google > agreement that made some noise earlier this year. >> >> The closing session offered summaries of the panels that had taken > place in parallel. A summary of the summaries was: "Free the > data!" (instead of keeping it in silos where it is difficult for > others to access and use). >> >> One of the visions that Jack Dangermond, founder and president of > Esri, shared, is that over more than 40 years in the field of GIS, > he had witnessed a few revolutionary technological changes: remote > sensing, GPS, and now, crowd-sourcing. >> >> The main points of Esri's presentations that might be of interest > here are: >> - the recently released version 2.0 of ArcGIS editor for OSM >> (https://esriosmeditor.codeplex.com/), >> - the general move towards "the cloud", with the ability to share > hundreds of thousands of maps online, even for those without their > own server, >> - the possibility to easily create (point) map layers from > spreadsheets (containing geo-coordinates columns) ("as easy as > drag and drop"), >> - data collection tools on mobile devices (directly derived from > data models). >> They also recalled that they have a program to supply software > licenses to nonprofit organizations, which could apply to HOT (at > least). >> >> HXL (Humanitarian eXchange Language) is a draft standard, > initiated by OCHA, designed to address the problem that > "information sharing is becoming the bottleneck to efficient aid". >> >> This conference allowed me to meet people from the Red Cross, > MapAction, UN-OCHA, USAID/OTI, ACTED,... and GIS and information > officers from South Sudan and Pakistan. By the way, who would like > to help organize a mapping party in Islamabad? >> >> I also had the pleasure to meet St?phane Henriod, who is > interested in natural disasters data and in contributing to OSM in > Tajikistan, as you may have seen on the HOT list, and Robert > Colombo, who was "the guy in the audience always asking many good, > thought provoking, questions" (and had activated SBTF, GisCorps > and HOT to collect health facilities info for Libya, from his > position at WHO in Tunis). And it was, as always, a pleasure to be > able to chat with Fred Moine, who must now be back in Haiti for > IOM. > Thanks to Mikel for introducing me to the panel moderator, and to > Nicolas for introducing me to his contacts who were likely to be > at the conference. >> >> But maybe the best surprise for me was an "African citizen" (who > works in the UN) who came to me after my presentation to tell me > that he thought that OSM could be a development and > democratization tool that African youths, who have for instance > contributed to the recent democratic change in Senegal, could use > to organize themselves and to manage their own communities. This > matched perfectly the vision that we had in Haiti with Nicolas... > So let's make it happen! >> >> Best wishes, >> >> Jean-Guilhem >> >> >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> HOT mailing list >> [email protected] >> http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot >> >> >> > -------------- next part -------------- > An HTML attachment was scrubbed... > URL: > <http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/hot/attachments/20120411/7002ea54/attachment.html> > > ------------------------------ > > _______________________________________________ > HOT mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot > > > End of HOT Digest, Vol 26, Issue 24 > *********************************** _______________________________________________ HOT mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
