I did my best to test SDS and I could not get it to work. Below are my findings.
Severin, Joseph, thank you to both of you for providing some direction. I am doing my test with very slim json and preset definitions: name/shop/category I tried to save one point. I have no idea what the problem is here. The json is attached, same as in the project definition, along with the presets, and the OSM test file. *Details* 1. I am using SDS plugin version 30416 2. The plugin (seems) to ship with an incorrect server url, so I changed it to: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org 3. I am on Windows 7 (yuck) 4. User link: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/users/5 (login: [email protected] , password: duywUV6KVn ) (this account no longer works? since password reset through web interface? 5. My "user-5" account, created by Kate is a member of the correct project 6. Project Link: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/projects/9 *Save/Load Locally* 1. When I save using the JOSM-SDS-menu-Save command the file cannot be saved to a network drive (no file appears at all). I can save to Desktop. I named the file with .osm extension but I don't know if that is correct or not, data remains readable in text editor, seems fine). 2. When opening an SDS file from the Desktop I get a "Preparing data set" retrying through 5 of 5... and eventually a no data found error. 3. My OSM test file is attached, along with presets and the JSON used. 4. Using the SDS-menu_Load command JOSM cannot "see" the saved sds.osm file on the Desktop 5. Manually entering the name of the file does not open the file. *Data UL/DL* 1. Any normal tags (non-sds-keyed tags) are saved to the OSM node, and uploaded to OSM as expected. 2. All normal data and tags (non-sds-keyed data) can be downloaded again from OSM, as expected. 3. No sds-keyed data is downloadable. Not expected. 4. Saving sds-keyed-data with a normal OSM file removes all SDS data. I think this is expected. 5. Polygon (closed way building) and node (as building/shop) were tried, both failed to be retrieved from SDS server, but non-sds data was retrievable from OSM. *Web Data Access* 1. Through the SDS status page I can see that my original Kate-created-user can indeed save data to the SDS site: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/status 2. I cannot find any way to view or edit the data through the SDS site. All links to such pages throw 500 errors or access warnings. 3. Searchby tag (ex shop) results in "no object is found" (there should be 2+ nodes and a closed way): http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/tagsearch?utf8=%E2%9C%93&change_project=9&tagstring=shop 4. When I download the area again, after upload, the general tags for OSM are pulled down, but no data from SDS is available *Users* 1. Any user I make through the SDS site cannot verify credentials through JOSM, whether admin or normal. user. a 500 error is generated. 2. Once I reset the password for my user-5 account, now I can no longer verify credentials through JOSM. (!!!!!!!!!!) -- Alex ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Alex Rollin <[email protected]> Date: Mon, Aug 4, 2014 at 6:34 PM Subject: Re: [HOT] SDS Preparation/Project-Setup To: Severin Menard <[email protected]>, Joseph Reeves < [email protected]> Severin, Joseph, thank you to both of you for providing some direction. I am doing my test with very slim json and preset definitions: name/shop/category I tried to save one point. I have no idea what the problem is here. The json is attached, same as in the project definition, along with the presets, and the OSM test file. *Details* 1. I am using SDS plugin version 30416 2. The plugin (seems) to ship with an incorrect server url, so I changed it to: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org 3. I am on Windows 7 (yuck) 4. User link: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/users/5 (login: [email protected] , password: duywUV6KVn ) (this account no longer works? since password reset through web interface? 5. My "user-5" account, created by Kate is a member of the correct project 6. Project Link: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/projects/9 *Save/Load Locally* 1. When I save using the JOSM-SDS-menu-Save command the file cannot be saved to a network drive (no file appears at all). I can save to Desktop. I named the file with .osm extension but I don't know if that is correct or not, data remains readable in text editor, seems fine). 2. When opening an SDS file from the Desktop I get a "Preparing data set" retrying through 5 of 5... and eventually a no data found error. 3. My OSM test file is attached, along with presets and the JSON used. 4. Using the SDS-menu_Load command JOSM cannot "see" the saved sds.osm file on the Desktop 5. Manually entering the name of the file does not open the file. *Data UL/DL* 1. Any normal tags (non-sds-keyed tags) are saved to the OSM node, and uploaded to OSM as expected. 2. All normal data and tags (non-sds-keyed data) can be downloaded again from OSM, as expected. 3. No sds-keyed data is downloadable. Not expected. 4. Saving sds-keyed-data with a normal OSM file removes all SDS data. I think this is expected. 5. Polygon (closed way building) and node (as building/shop) were tried, both failed to be retrieved from SDS server, but non-sds data was retrievable from OSM. *Web Data Access* 1. Through the SDS status page I can see that my original Kate-created-user can indeed save data to the SDS site: http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/status 2. I cannot find any way to view or edit the data through the SDS site. All links to such pages throw 500 errors or access warnings. 3. Searchby tag (ex shop) results in "no object is found" (there should be 2+ nodes and a closed way): http://sds.dev.hotosm.org/tagsearch?utf8=%E2%9C%93&change_project=9&tagstring=shop 4. When I download the area again, after upload, the general tags for OSM are pulled down, but no data from SDS is available *Users* 1. Any user I make through the SDS site cannot verify credentials through JOSM, whether admin or normal. user. a 500 error is generated. 2. Once I reset the password for my user-5 account, now I can no longer verify credentials through JOSM. (!!!!!!!!!!)
SDS_Kitchen_Building_test.osm
Description: Binary data
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <presets xmlns="http://josm.openstreetmap.de/tagging-preset-1.0";> <item name="Kitchen" id.name="Dapur" icon="_maki/_pink/shop-24.svg" type="node"> <label text="Kitchen - definition" en.text="Kitchen - definition" id.text="Dapur - definisi"/> <label text="________________________________________"/> <space /> <label text="Use a capital letter to start each word in the name of the location. ex: Example:Kedai Telapak, Bank Negara Indonesia. Negative example: bank ni, bni, BANK" en.text="Use a capital letter to start each word in the name of the location." id.text="Gunakan huruf kapital untuk memulai setiap kata dalam nama. Contoh: Kedai Telapak, Bank Negara Indonesia. Contoh Tidak: bank ni, bni, BANK "/> <space /> <text key="routes:name" text="Name" en.text="Name" id.text="Nama" /> <key key="building" value="retail" /> <key key="routes:shop" value="kitchen" /> <key key="routes:category" value="Kitchen" /> </item> </presets>
sds_json_KITCHENSHOP.json
Description: application/json
_______________________________________________ HOT mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
