Clan names from the import had problems with truncation, as far as I recall, so they would have to be verified.
On Sat, 22 Nov 2014 15:01 Andrew Buck <[email protected]> wrote: > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- > Hash: SHA1 > > I am not sure this is worth doing, at least not manually. GIS > software can draw enclosing polygons around the common clan entries > and then these could be used to the same effect, with a lot less > manual work. > > However in any case, I think we need to ask if deriving them this way > is the best way to go anyway. The data likely already exists > somewhere, so our efforts may be better spent trying to free that data > than trying to recreate a rough copy of it. > > - -AndrewBuck > > > On 11/22/2014 07:39 AM, Rafael Avila Coya wrote: > > Hi all: > > > > I was doing some testing on manually tracing the clan boundaries > > of Liberia from the UNMIL places data. That data includes, for the > > huge majority of the 14,020 nodes, the clan each place belongs to, > > and also the district and county. > > > > There are 15 counties, divided in a total of 90 districts, and it > > seems all of those boundaries are already in OSM (correct me if I > > am wrong). > > > > I would suggest to do this by one or two people, with experience > > in making boundaries. We should agree in a tagging schema, to > > avoid inconsistencies (it would be mainly for the source tag). > > Needless to say, I offer myself on doing this. > > > > To speed up the thing, here is my proposal for the tagging: > > > > Segments: > > > > boundary=administrative admin_level=8 source=estimate (or something > > similar) > > > > Maybe source:description=Data derivated from the UNMIL place nodes > > > > Relations: > > > > type=boundary boundary=administrative name=* admin_level=8 > > source=UNMIL source:description=Data derivated from the UNMIL place > > nodes > > > > We would include the admin_centre of all clans (when easily > > guessed) as member of each relation, adding to it the capital=8 > > tag. We could also check if all districts have their admin_centre > > as member. If not, we would add it, tagging it with capital=6. > > > > Any problems, like having to change the district borders or other > > issues, we would discuss them before doing such changes. > > > > Cheers, > > > > Rafael. > > > > > > > > _______________________________________________ HOT mailing list > > [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot > > > > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- > Version: GnuPG v1 > > iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJUcJbSAAoJEK7RwIfxHSXbTpoP/3Hjk7uA7D8g6+HobV0HAGYu > ncZEofun+LOZSiQA9cYVGgAn5Q2NEdk3Patet2IJvEEj6WjA6R7g9VUngFSd1ihv > M4uZCgivt6uLLUaPoXlPw794GVDLZAzUj94q3oEDjcJIafIZTEdPFbK2VcglaMe8 > +8vkQ04mFHeunNCnHKOM/kQ0fyyDCCwa5KuaJ2MkuMHp9f3uyFMxPzDb0wWIBXKb > qP6R68k0JGpK+e3Qwe+1YAoWD+InlhgggRYATZcXHLfOeivxk6ZZaurGxgMvLOIC > FGCs1nrNwUaMzp7r2Wq9K/tTCkI0TQsUa+chKJmCQyjg2V3DH0WSNooHGqW+JBIZ > HLrrcoO6rFL+YPfaDRwo+j6pDFK5EACG9V9UWMZ3Qf23tBYNL2K3w0OFVlqckZOl > wGoaMRvG79JXq0WEVYKtT9UgGt6sKr0V6vAZn+wd6PSzey+OWO3Vc5XKxg7xI8sp > G9bZAeOUZyUiThcF72PfWqeg+P6fkbjrWLXUYz1omWhOnO26I5PM0nuQAB4jUKEY > DmT89r72xltEn1byMZq5Joz5p61eNJHPJg4S9p0l9vmdjyFdWgUvUoUM/taXuY7j > DGEoZ65aFx811I3JfdKKADRPFUFvo9ITqTMA+phtPnt4pVDY/qgGdTCGVZOKYysr > 05y7gyS0XW6ALrjrrKYn > =RsoD > -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- > > _______________________________________________ > HOT mailing list > [email protected] > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot >
_______________________________________________ HOT mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/hot
