On 28 Jul., 09:43, Jeffrey Martin <[email protected]> wrote: > I've seen Kay suggesting that Hugin should be carefully "rebooted" i.e. not > totally rewritten, but partially rewritten, and built with proper > documentation etc. > > I can't help with that, but I'm wondering, as a thought experiment - how > much time are we talking about for this to be done? How many man-years? 1? > 5? 20?
In my experience recreating a software by rewriting takes much less time than the first 'incarnation'. The trick is not to try and create something very different and 'vastly superior' but just to recreate what you have in a clean fashion. But now you do it top-down: you have a clear idea of what the outcome should be, which you couldn't have had on the outset because software often grows in unexpected ways. Coming top-down, you can cleanly design that part which has grown by accretion or just chaotically in the original design. Eventually you reach a layer where you need just the routines which you already have and often you can just copy and paste them. It's like putting the thing back on it's feet. In fact, your term 'rebooting' is also quite apt. The looming five or twenty or 65 man years question musn't keep us from asking: - how many man years we have to invest in bug hunting in undocumented or convoluted code (inscrutability) - how many man years it costs to refacture parts bit by bit, trying to mend them while they are still in the same interface (inertia/ cohesion) - how many man years of development time we will never have at our disposal because potential contributors won't put up with the code/ documentation as-is (discouragement) - how many man years we have to invest in helping users and developers who are undaunted but still can't figure it out, and how often we fail to help because we can't figure it out ourselves (ignorance) - what trouble we'd find ourselves in if key developers can't/won't contribute anymore and we have to learn what they did by reading their code (dependence) ... and I only wrote these off the top of my head and I suppose there's more skeletons in the cupboard eating man years. Some of these man-time consuming effects are certainly already troubling the project. Kay -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Hugin and other free panoramic software" group. A list of frequently asked questions is available at: http://wiki.panotools.org/Hugin_FAQ To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/hugin-ptx
