On 13 Aug., 22:48, Yuval Levy <[email protected]> wrote:
> On August 11, 2011 01:00:22 pm kfj wrote:

> Well, the bus (or vessel) I am looking for is a basic Python framework to
> start tinkering with.  If you look at Hugin, this is how it started:  a basic,
> empty wxWidget/C++ shell.  I already had a basic wxPython thing working, and I
> even found access to OpenGL and displayed an interactive equirectangular
> within a primitive Python GUI.  But I know that this is the wrong way to go
> about.  I need help designing the architecture to avoid getting into spaghetti
> code territory.

I spent half a day surfing and inverstigating, looking for a suitable
substrate. Of course much more time needs to be spent on this, but it
helped getting a clearer idea of what I'd like. I remember some time
ago commenting that I was glad hugin didn't switch to Qt and the
comment Simon Oosthoek sent in

http://groups.google.com/group/hugin-ptx/browse_thread/thread/5994c42551f7d1a9/272bc4a8ccd92b32?lnk=gst&q=FUD+Qt#272bc4a8ccd92b32

On 23 Jun., 11:23, Simon Oosthoek <[email protected]> wrote:
> On 23/06/11 09:57, kfj wrote:
>
> > I'm glad you didn't. I have a funny feeling withQt. They might decide
> > suddenly they aren't licensing this or the other component to the free
> > world anymore or putting restrictions on whatQt-based code can be
> > used for. I feel much more comfortable with wxWidgets, never mind it's
> > probably not (yet) as evolved and polished.
>
> It's a shame that the old "reason" that spawned GNOME (Qtwasn't "Free"
> at that time) is still causingFUD(no doubt unintentionalFUD) like
> this.Qtis currently completely free software to the point that RMS
> endorses it (article from sept. 2000, a still somewhat sceptical 
> RMS:http://www.linuxtoday.com/news_story.php3?ltsn=2000-09-05-001-21-OP-L...).

when having a good long look at what Qt (and it's python binding pyQt)
offer and what the license is, and remembering Simon's comment, I have
to swallow my words and say the opposite: I suppose it would have been
a good move. There it is - most of what we could want in one neat
package. The scope seems to be wider than wxWidget's. We could just
use their SQL interface for the data carrying, the openGL interface
for the display side of things, not to mention all the GUI stuff.

Now this is just a preliminary result I've come up with, but the
number of candidates for a powerful python application framework which
isn't web-based doesn't seem too large.

> > > Do you want to set up a project on Github?
>
> > I'm not sure if we're there yet,

what I mean is that we should spend a good long time browsing for the
very foundation to build stuff on before we even consider setting up a
project. If we'd switch to a different GUI framework, everything would
become much more involved anyway, although the idea to just basically
clone hugin with different means would be still a good policy, as it
lowers the complexity of the task by not asking us to redisign the UI
at the same time.

Strangely enough hugin's GUI is what I have the least problem with,
yet a good framework qualifies by integrating all aspects well.
wxWidget's scope is more that of a GUI tool, but I'd wish for a much
more comprehensive set of tools to simplify development.

But my hope is that a good framework will take so much load off the
development by providing a readymade infrastructure, that the work
will be more interesting - basically doing application-specific stuff
rather than bothering with making everything work together.

once we're there,

> > Since it'd be a FOSS project, we might have the repository hosted
> > with bitbucket. Anything wrong with that?
>
> Wrong? not at all.  I've just noticed that they use Hg and that they are free
> for FOSS projects.  I have no experience of Bitbucket and I don't recall why,
> back in early 2010 when I was doing my research I did not hit on that.  We
> ended up migrating to Hg in May 2010 and staying on SF.  I see on the BB
> homepage that they have been acquired by Atlassian in September 2010.  Maybe
> the change brought in by Atlassian has made them into that attractive outfit
> that they are now?

Bruno also seems to think it's a good idea:

On 14 Aug., 00:20, Bruno Postle <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> I've been using bitbucket for a while.  I haven't had any
> connectivity issues, and the various web tools are all very fast.  I
> like that the wiki data is also stored in HG, though I haven't used
> the tracker or much else other than the HG repository.


> > I think we need something
> > for brainstorming and structuring. Any suggestions?
>
> My wish would be a Skype conference call.

We can try that, but I'm not sure if it's going to be so effective. I
think the written word has it's advantages - it's browsable, to
mention one thing. Bit slower, but more structured. Maybe we could set
up a new ML for the topic rather than cluttering hugin-ptx (we could
always do a bit of cross-posting to lure people over :)

I also wonder if we shouldn't plain ask for help. Our question is
simple: We want a powerful python-based cross-platform application
framework to write a hugin clone with as little fuss as possible. I
wonder where we should post such a question, but I'm sure we'd benefit
from outside intelligence. Any ideas?

> But my notebook is down.  I am
> waiting for the replacement HDD to arrive and my workstation's A/V is
> suboptimal.

It's a shame your system's down. Because

> When are you going to the mountains again?

as soon as the weather stabilizes. You remember, I didn't want to get
involved with the GSoC stuff because I'm here and away erratically
during the summer. It might even get worse in the winter if I go to
the Himalaya - I'm not sure yet what I'll do. I can work there, but
web access there is usually very slow, so it's better for pure
programming and conceptual work.

Kay

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Hugin and other free panoramic software" group.
A list of frequently asked questions is available at: 
http://wiki.panotools.org/Hugin_FAQ
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/hugin-ptx

Reply via email to