I agree with you Andy, I think the draft still is not clear, AB
On 6/23/13, Andy Bierman <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi, > > If an I2RS client wants to set up a tunnel between 2 routers > (as a lame example), does it send 1 request to 1 I2RS agent > or 2 requests, 1 to each I2RS agent/router? If 1 request, is the > southbound > protocol between the I2RS agent and at least 1 router proprietary > or part of the standard? > > I think this draft should be clear about what is in scope. > It seems to say that the southbound protocol is out of scope. > > > Andy > > > On Sun, Jun 23, 2013 at 2:16 AM, Abdussalam Baryun < > [email protected]> wrote: > >> I beleive if any thing not shown then they are not allowed by I2RS, if >> it is shown then it is the way the I2RS will work to solve the >> problem. So I will understand that I2RS client does not talk to NE but >> only to the agent, that is why I suggest that we don't show any sign >> that the client can talk to any other as long it is out of scope. >> Therefore the drawing methodology (figure 1) is : (if out of scope of >> the protocol then should not be shown, and if future work of protocol >> it may be shown). >> >> AB >> >> On 6/22/13, Andy Bierman <[email protected]> wrote: >> > Hi, >> > >> > I just re-read the framework and problem statement drafts. >> > Only 1 minor issue in the problem statement draft: >> > >> > The 'I2RS Agent' is shown as a single box in figure 1. >> > >> > 1) Does this mean the protocol between the "broker" and the >> > NEs is proprietary, or just not shown? >> > >> > 2) Does this mean that an I2RS Client never talks directly to an NE >> > or does it mean all I2RS Agent functionality is available on all >> NEs? >> > >> > Nit, sec. 6, para 4: >> > - the lack of standard data models is the problem of the NETMOD WG, >> > not really the NETCONF protocol. >> > - s/may help define needed/may require help defining needed/ >> > >> > >> > Andy >> > >> > _______________________________________________ i2rs mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/i2rs
