On Sat, 6 Oct 2012 16:36:06 -0400, John Gilmore wrote:

>Gerhard Postpischil is of course quite right that RECFM=VBS can be
>used without segment descriptors, although FORTRAN and PL/I
>data-directed I/O do still use them.
> 
Not as I read the document cited earlier.  VB data sets have RDWs;
VBS data sets must have SDWs.  It's irrelevant(1) that the SDW
for a single-segment nonempty logical record in a VBS data set is
identical to the RDW of a logical record with identical content in a VB
data set.  VBS data sets have only SDWs, not RDWs (read carefully;
I'd be delighted to be persuaded otherwise), and by specification
the minimum count in an SDW is 5.

(1) Even as the occurrence of the word "six" in French text
is a French word, not the similar English word; nor does this
generalize to allowing arbitrary use of English words in French
writing.  L'Académie française would insist otherwise.

Thanks for the citation.  And I've given you a rare opportunity
to disagree with Shmuel and me simultaneously.

-- gil

----------------------------------------------------------------------
For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN

Reply via email to