[JS: bounced to me "header line too long" so I snip the header again. Martin, can you trim your mail header before you post? Thanks.]
At 12:15 01/10/28 +0800, xiang deng wrote: >On Sunday, October 28, 2001 10:49 AM, Martin Duerst wrote: > > This is a valid concern. It is ultimately a policy issue. But > > it should be possible to produce some data/guidelines (e.g. as > > an informational RFC) that registrars/registries can adopt. > > > It is much easier in such a context to deal with 1-n correspondences > > than it is if an actual mapping is required. > >Thanks. > > > >2). multiple registrations in DNS can solve a part of the issue, How to > > >solve the > > >delegation issue of subdomain and keep the consistency. > > >it's technology issue. > > > I'm not really a DNS expert, but I think with something called > > CNAME or DNAME, there is a very easy solution that will keep > > consistency. > >No, we can't keep consistency. >Mr. James has agree with my opinion. Can somebody who really knows the DNS details please answer this: Assume somebody registers SSSS as a domain with name servers,... and registers TTTT CNAME SSSS, why would that not guarantee that everybody looking for foo.SSSS and for foo.TTTT would get to the same machine(s)? > > >3). if we provide multiple registration solution for customs, we must > > >guarantee the multiple > > >records belong to one custom. but from technology view, we can not > > >guarantee it. > > > It's the customer's job to do that, and the registrar's job > > to help them. No need for this WG to do anything. > >If the fact is as your said. If a user register a domain name which include >Chinese characters, he must register all variant forms of the domain name. No. What I'm assuming is that s/he registers two forms, an all-simplified and an all-traditional form. That's the customer's responsibility. The rules I mentioned in my answer to your point 1), if applied, then would guarantee that nobody else can register a name that is a mixture of simplified and traditional characters of the already registered names. >Then he can protect his intelligent property of this domain name. >why? just because he want register a Chinese domain name? >This answer will not satisfy any person. Registering a lot of domain names won't satisfy anybody. But registering two domain names should not be too bad, I think. Regards, Martin.
