A reminder: Please avoid engaging in engineering discussions for the moment. We're discussing the proposed new charter and whether it's appropriate for a rechartering of DKIM to develop DKIM2.
I would also suggest we table the discussion about what we call this. There's nothing saying a working group called DKIM2 must produce something by that name and not a new thing called BFNEAS (Bron's Funky New Email Authentication Scheme). It's typical that these be aligned, but it is not mandatory. There is a chance that if we do a good job of resolving the charter, we can avoid the need for a BoF altogether. If the discussion is muddied, this process will avoidably drag out and we will ultimately need at least an interim BoF if not a formal one in Bangkok, which is months away. If the charter is solid and the answers to the typical BoF questions are evident from the list, I'd say our chances are greatest of getting this off to a quick and healthy start. There's no WG formed so WG list rules don't apply here, but I nevertheless implore you all to consider the following things temporarily off-topic unless they contribute directly to that specific mission: * how DKIM2 should work * what we don't like about the original DKIM * what it should be called * how and whether to deal with replays * bounce handling under the proposed scheme * how the "changes" algebra should work or be implemented * what criteria exist for what acceptable "changes" are * anything at all having to do with DMARC * anything at all having to do with ARC * spam filtering topics generally * the history of "l=" in DKIM * things that are the provenance of another working group (especially EMAILCORE) * use of AI to solve any of the above * the current weather system hitting the US west coast * whether "rich of peak" or "lean of peak" operation in piston engine aircraft is superior * how Pete scared my daughter that one time * split vs. solid fins or Nitrox vs. air during SCUBA excursions * (your ad here) Thank you. -MSK, ART AD
_______________________________________________ Ietf-dkim mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
