> From: Keith Moore [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 

> No, Dave, you insisted on interrupting me and shouting me 
> down when I tried to raise these issues in the BOFs - doing 
> your best to prevent me from making my case.  And you're not 
> just one voice, you are one of the document authors.  
> 
> As for rough consensus, you seem to forget that there are two 
> necessary conditions for standardization - one is rough 
> consensus, the other is technical soundness.  

It is seldom the case that I agree with Dave Crocker on anything. I don't 
remember Dave being a nuisance at the DKIM meeting I attended, I admit I did 
miss one of them.

If one gets shouted down in a BOF the usual recourse is to take it to the WG 
mailing list or to the IETF list.

I am still waiting to see a description of the defects you believe that you 
have identified in either forum. I have asked you to describe them here several 
times, you have refused.


_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
[email protected]
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf

Reply via email to