On Sun, 2009-01-04, Dave CROCKER wrote:
>> From: ACME Chief Officers:
>> Alice <[email protected]>,
>> Bob <[email protected]>;
>>
>> There must have been *some* concept of email that dictated that a message
>> could be sent *to* a group but not *from* one!
> I don't remember whether this idea came up during discussions for RFC 733. I
> don't think so, although it certainly seems to me to be as reasonable to be
> able
> to apply the construct to the author field as to a recipient field. But since
> the construct so infrequently used, I'm not sure it's all that helpful to
> explore this "enhancement"...
Well, this prompted me to go searching the RFCs, and I found out that the
"From: group: ... ;" construct WAS allowed in RFCs 724 and 733 but was
removed in 822. There are examples showing exactly this construct in the
earlier RFCs (724: II.D.i and 733: V.C.9), but the corresponding example
has been changed in 822 (A.2.7) and a note added specifically saying:
Note that the name
of the committee cannot be specified, since <group> names are
not permitted in the From field.
I'd love to see the discussion that brought about that change. :-)
Anyway, this tangent has probably run it's course, so I'll drop it on this
list.
--
Bill McQuillan <[email protected]>
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf
