On 9/5/2012 7:51 AM, SM wrote:
...
Creating a perpetual I-D archive for the sake of rfcdiff is not a good
idea as it goes against the notion of letting an I-D expire gracefully.

+1

Let's not forget there was a reason for expiration.

I'm OK with the archive being public so long as at least the authors can remove an ID *without needing to provide a reason*.

Yes, removal from the IETF site will not expunge copies from the entire Internet, but the IETF site should set the example here, and respect the original intent of allowing an ID to expire.

Joe

Reply via email to