> From: Christoph Hormann [mailto:[email protected]] > Sent: Monday, May 13, 2013 2:47 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: Re: [OSM-talk] ADD import (Antarctica natural features and > POIs) > > > There does not seem to be any serious objection so i am going to proceed > converting the data. > > Two minor changes: > > - use capacity:persons instead of capacity for the research station > capacity value. > - only maintain the ADD:* tags derived from the original data attributes > for the coastlines and POIs, not for the streams. It is doubtful how > useful this data will be in the future. In case of the coastline it > could help deciding on future updates though (since age and resolution > of the ADD data varies quite a lot).
It's good to see Antarctica getting some attention. I neglected to comment on the message on the 5th, but I wanted to comment on your proposed tags. You are proposing ADD:code, ADD:date, ADD:text, ADD:source, and ADD:revision. The current wisdom is to not include these type of tags. The code duplicates the other OSM tags and is wrong as soon as someone reclassifies a feature. Date, text and revision are not documented on the wiki page so it's hard to see what purpose they serve. ADD:source would be better off as a source tag. ADD:temporal and ADD:status seem unnecessary given the information is in the seasonal and abandoned tags. Some of the ways could really use a simplify. I'm not sure what the appropriate value is, but there are some runs of 20 nodes in 13b a straight line which simplify down to 2 nodes. The grounding lines seem the most prone to this. What tags do you plan to use on the changesets, and what size changesets are you planning to use? _______________________________________________ Imports mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
