I've confirmed, IMHO all deletable. Some of them are non-duplicate, and may compatible to other tag. But they are very old information, and easy to look up from original information.
Please tell me if they must be kept. > Talk-ja ML * KSJ2インポートのいくつかのTagは、参照として使える情報がいくつか残っています。 * 前回のインポートの情報はとても古い(2006年くらい？)であること、 * Wayに所属しているNodeに振られた情報を削除したいこと、および * どうしても必要な場合は原典のファイルをみればよいので、 * いちど削除してしまいたいのですが、よいでしょうか？ > Talk-ja == Deletable KSJ2 tag == * non duplicate info, but seems deletable KSJ2:ADS = 字エビノ木4745 / May compatible to addr:* (partial) KSJ2:AdminArea = 静岡県三島市 / May compatible to addr:* (partial) KSJ2:LIN = 伊野線 / May compatible to network=* KSJ2:OPC = 土佐電氣鐵道 / May compatible to operator:* KSJ2:PubFacAdmin = 民間 / May compatible to operator=* (Partial information, I think deletable) * Deletable KSJ2:ARE KSJ2:LPN KSJ2:coordinate KSJ2:curve_id KSJ2:curve_type KSJ2:lake_id KSJ2:lat KSJ2:long KSJ2:INT KSJ2:INT_label KSJ2:COP_label KSJ2:DFD KSJ2:RAC KSJ2:RAC_label KSJ2:LOC KSJ2:RIC KSJ2:RIN KSJ2:WSC KSJ2:filename KSJ2:river_id * Deletable keys, ADDITIONAL KSJ2:segment KSJ2:STN KSJ2:RAS KSJ2:AAC KSJ2:AAC_label KSJ2:HOW KSJ2:LDM KSJ2:AAC 2013/9/14 Paul Norman <[email protected]> > Any issues with changing this to the following? All tags have >100k uses > and > seem to be duplicating other information already present, or not of any > interest to OSM. > > KSJ2:ADS > KSJ2:ARE > KSJ2:AdminArea > KSJ2:COP_label > KSJ2:DFD > KSJ2:INT > KSJ2:INT_label > KSJ2:LOC > KSJ2:LPN > KSJ2:OPC > KSJ2:PubFacAdmin > KSJ2:RAC > KSJ2:RAC_label > KSJ2:RIC > KSJ2:RIN > KSJ2:WSC > KSJ2:coordinate > KSJ2:curve_id > KSJ2:curve_type > KSJ2:filename > KSJ2:lake_id > KSJ2:lat > KSJ2:long > KSJ2:river_id > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Paul Norman [mailto:[email protected]] > > Sent: Saturday, September 07, 2013 8:27 PM > > To: 'Satoshi IIDA' > > Cc: [email protected]; 'OpenStreetMap Japanese talk' > > Subject: Re: [Imports] Deletable KSJ2 import tags > > > > > From: Satoshi IIDA [mailto:[email protected]] > > > Sent: Saturday, September 07, 2013 3:33 AM > > > Subject: Re: [Imports] Deletable KSJ2 import tags > > > > > > I think all the those tags are deletable. > > > > Unless someone objects I'll be going with the following tags as some of > > the ones I listed earlier occur very seldom: > > > > KSJ2:ARE > > KSJ2:COP_label > > KSJ2:DFD > > KSJ2:LOC > > KSJ2:LPN > > KSJ2:RIC > > KSJ2:RIN > > KSJ2:WSC > > KSJ2:coordinate > > KSJ2:curve_id > > KSJ2:curve_type > > KSJ2:filename > > KSJ2:lake_id > > KSJ2:lat > > KSJ2:long > > > > > It was added because of the issue of interpretation of licensing > > > words, and it is now cleared. > > > (We JP confirmed it, tagging "source", "source_ref", and "note:ja" are > > > enough, as written in KSJ2 page) > > > > > > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalogue/Japan_KSJ2_Import > > > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ja/2012-November/006930. > > > html > > > > Just to clarify, there are no *legal* reasons that source, source_ref > > and note:ja cannot be removed by anyone at any time. > > > > Of course doing that in bulk to the osm.org database wouldn't be done, > > but is legally possible and downstream consumers do it all the time to > > their derivative databases. > > > > > > _______________________________________________ > > Imports mailing list > > [email protected] > > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports > > -- Satoshi IIDA mail: [email protected] twitter: @nyampire
_______________________________________________ Imports mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
