Perhaps Citrus is one of the genera with lot of taxonomic confusions, equally 
so in common names. What we commonly call as oranges (santara) is Mandarine (R. 
reticulata) for western world and what we know as Mousambi or Malta are oranges 
for West (C. sinensis). Spines  on young shoots, presence and size of petiole 
wings, size of petals, size of fruit, colour, thickness of rind, and how easily 
it can be peeled off, numberof  fruit segments and colour of seed leaves 
(cotyledons) are features helpful in identification. A note of these together 
with photographs should be help a lot..

Gurcharan Singh 
  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Padmanabhan Geetha 
  To: Gurcharan Singh-sify 
  Cc: Dinesh Valke ; Indian Tree Pix 
  Sent: Sunday, August 09, 2009 6:37 PM
  Subject: Re: [indiantreepix:15557] Re: Citron - Citrus medica | ID 
confirmation req 11JUNAR01


  Dear friends

  The  Wikipedia gives the Tamil name for C.hystirx as kolumichai 
('கொலுமிச்சை') in tamil. 
  Some people call kolumichai as  kadarangai, but i am not sure whether they 
mean the same plant. 

  In one of the issues of Current Science i discovered that C medica  is called 
Kadarangai 

  Kadarangai is a fairly big tree.I am familiar with this tree too as it grew 
in my parent's house at Chennai. It's fruits are large, much bigger than that 
of narthangai. The fruits are green initially and then turn yellow. It was 
often pickled in the same way as the sour lime எலுமிச்சை elumiccai. 

  This was the information in Current Science the journal from IISc Banglore ( 
ref : http://www.ias.ac.in/jarch/currsci/43/00000288.pdf)
  C aurantifolia - Lime
  C reticulata  -   Kamla orange
  C sinensis  -    Orange
  C limettioides - Kolunji
  C medica      - Kadarangai


  Some more searches and readings reveal that the common  varieties of citrus 
fruits that we use today were all classified initially as  C medica; for eg 
Citrus aurantiifolia, used to be Citrus medica var. acida

  Thus i think that some of these changes have perhaps not  been incoporated in 
all texts ( esp what  we get from the net) and therefore  a lot of confusion. I 
remember reading Aparnaji's mail several months ago where she warned us that  
identification would not always be possible from photos unless we have several 
details of  the plants. Gurcharanji's pointers about characteristics of the 
winged petiole is an eg of Aparnaji's alert

  I guess there fore that C medica could be a name given to narthanga, 
kadaranga, elumiccai and  would probably not be wrong in a general sense.

  Of course my conclusions are general and  please feel free to correct me 
where ever needed.


  best wishes
  geetha 



  On Sun, Aug 9, 2009 at 9:39 AM, Gurcharan Singh-sify <[email protected]> wrote:

    After seeing the photograph shot by  Geetha I had a second look at Citrus 
species and am inclined to identify it with C. hystrix DC. This species has 
winged petiole more than half as long as leaf blade and crenulate leaves, fruit 
5-7 cm.

    Gurcharan Singh
      ----- Original Message ----- 
      From: Padmanabhan Geetha 
      To: Dinesh Valke 
      Cc: Indian Tree Pix 
      Sent: Sunday, August 09, 2009 10:06 AM
      Subject: [indiantreepix:15557] Re: Citron - Citrus medica | ID 
confirmation req 11JUNAR01


      Dinesh ji
      Thank you for persisting with the Citrus. I am thanking you more so 
because your queries made me look at the narthangai plant again (A lesson in 
observation!) and I noticed that it  had thorns.Something that the photo posted 
by Mr. Raghu Ananth does not show. Again i do not know if  the plant he has 
photographed is/could be a hybrid variety. These days several varieties of 
plants  that originally had thorns are produced minus these natural protectors! 

       I am attaching with this mail a photo of the narthangai plant growing in 
my garden. Too early for it to fruit, so only leaves and branches are seen  in 
the photo.This much i can vouch for - it is narthangai plant. It was grown from 
the seeds of the fruit.

       Which species of Citrus it is  I do not know. 
       I do hope that this  helps
      best wishes
      geetha 


      On Fri, Aug 7, 2009 at 6:46 PM, Dinesh Valke <[email protected]> 
wrote:

        ... re-surfacing this ID request.
        I do not think this to be Citrus medica.

        Could it be some variety or subspecies of Citrus aurantium ?
        Geetha ji's firm belief that it is known by the name narthangai in 
Tamil, led me to a WIKI page at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_orange

        Please comment.
        Regards.





         
        ---------- Forwarded message ----------
        From: raghu ananth <[email protected]>
        Date: Sat, Jul 11, 2009 at 3:14 PM
        Subject: [indiantreepix:14461] Citron - Citrus medica | ID confirmation 
req 11JUNAR01
        To: [email protected]



        Citron - Citrus medica. (Request to confirm the ID. )
        Rough Lime,  
        http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citron
        Local Name : Herale kai, Herale hannu (fruit)(Kannada), Nartanga (Tamil)

        kavalau Katta, Unchalli falls, Uttara Kannada, Karnataka
        Jun 2009


        Tough to find this fruiting tree in villages these days. Very few 
people sell this fruit in the market. Is it because people prefer Lemon or 
Sweet lime ?
        The juice of this fruit is considered good for some diseases and 
commonly used to prepare a dish called `yellow rice`.

        Regards
        Raghu Ananth

              Order: Sapindales
             
              Family: Rutaceae
             
              Genus: Citrus
             
              Species: C. medica
             
              Order: Sapindales
             
              Family: Rutaceae
             
              Genus: Citrus
             
              Species: C. medica
             



------------------------------------------------------------------------
        See the Web's breaking stories, chosen by people like you. Check out 
Yahoo! Buzz.



      



--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"indiantreepix" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.co.in/group/indiantreepix?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to