Respected members,

I am a silent reader of this group and enjoy learning about Indian flora
here. Although I have mentioned this once before, I feel compelled
to reiterate my displeasure at the slack attitude of the scientific
community vis-à-vis citation of sources.

An uninformed, gullible reader could easily be misled into believing that
Dr Bhagyashri Ranade (/ Madhuri Raut) is the author of the text in her
email. In fact, the "detailed information" posted by her has clearly
been copied from various sources with nary a credit or acknowledgment.

The first sentence, "*blooms are conical ... greenish bract*", has been
copied from Matt Glenn's site:
http://www.easybloom.com/plantlibrary/plant/peace-lily-1

The next two sentences, "*an individual flower consist(s) of a central
female structure  ... when they are actually producing pollen*", have
been copied from the fifth paragraph under the subhead "That beautiful
spathe. Is it really a flower?" on this site:
http://www.exoticrainforest.com/Spathiphyllum%20Clevelandii%20%20pc.htm

The next two sentences, "*Flowering lasts 9 to 12 days ... all over the
spadix during the male phase*", have been copied from the penultimate
paragraph of Todd Boland's article 'Peace Lily Revisited':
http://davesgarden.com/guides/articles/view/1953/

The next four sentences, "*The female flowers open first ... attracted to
the flowers by their odour*", have been lifted from the antepenultimate
paragraph of the aforementioned source, and the following sentence, "*In
the morning hours ... soap-like fragrance*", from the penultimate paragraph
of the same source.

The next sentence, "*The flowers turn green ... and seed has been
set*", appears
in the comment posted by Aboutflowers.com [dated August 2010] on this site:
http://www.aboutflowers.com/flower-a-plant-information-and-photos/plants/spathiphyllum.html

The last two sentences, "*The fruit and its seeds ripen ... becomes soft
and yellow*", have been copied from the final two paragraphs of Phoebe
Strauss' article on this site:
http://www.ehow.com/how_7994524_seeds-peace-lily-ripe.html

I strongly disapprove of such misappropriation. Anybody who can exert the
effort to indulge in such a copy-paste operation would certainly be capable
of citing the source without breaking a sweat.

I believe a group such as this ought to seriously focus on improving the
essential credibility of the scientific interaction it hosts.

With regards, Aggie Daman

On Thu, Jan 26, 2012 at 11:27 AM, Madhuri Raut <[email protected]> wrote:

> Dec 2011 and Jan 2012
>
> Sharing images of Spathiphyllum wallisii at a private society at Pune
>
> Family Araceae
>
> Common name Peace lily
>
> Blooms are conical clumps of small flowers borne on a stalk surrounded by
> a large white or greenish bract.  An individual flower consists of a
> central female structure with a stigma at its center and several male
> flowers surrounding that stigma.   These male flowers are difficult to
> observe except during male anthesis when they are actually producing
> pollen. Flowering lasts 9 to 12 days (although the attractive white spathe
> may be evident for weeks), with the female phase lasting 4 to 5 days,
> followed immediately by the male phase of 4 to 6 days. Pollen is
> continuously produced all over the spadix during the male phase. The female
> flowers open first (i.e., are receptive to pollen) and after a period of
> time, ‘close'. Once closed the males open to release pollen. This delay
> between male and female flowers prevents self-pollination. Pollination is
> mostly via flies, bees or beetles that are attracted to the flowers by
> their odour. In the morning hours, plants produce a spicy to soap-like
> fragrance
>
> The flowers turn green when they have been pollinated and seed has been
> set. The fruit and its seeds ripen four to six months after pollination.When
> ripe the spadix becomes soft and yellow
> --
> Regards
> Dr.Bhagyashri Ranade
>

Reply via email to