On Fri, 3 Jun 2011, [email protected] wrote:
> Hello Fedora Infra Team members,
>
> I just wanted to explore Fedora and visited the site. The motivation was
> enough to encourage me to pitch in and contribute whatever I can. So I went
> to register myself and
> that turned out to be both a discouraging as well as a encouraging experience.
>
> The captcha system was very bad and I had to spent about 45 mins before ricky
> (IRC Nick) did it for me. I found some major lapses in this particular thing.
> I was informed by
> ricky that things would be better in the next update, but let me give some
> suggestions that might help you in building the next system a better system.
>
> First regarding the captcha that did my day:
> 1. There wasn't ant documentation about the type of the captcha, whether it
> is a case sensitive or a case insensitive one. It could have been put
> straight away in the page
> or as a tool tip.
> 2. There wasn't a way to reload or get a alternate captcha image if one
> couldn't make out whats in there.
> 3. The captcha image itself was flawed. Generally its wise to put
> distortions in one color and the text in other color or at least different
> shade of the same color.
> 4. Finally there wasn't a audio captcha for people who get confused with
> distorted images. I accept this one as a luxury, but the previous three were
> very important.
> The user interface of the FAS site itself isn't that well built. To be exact,
> there could be more AJAXification of things. One doesn't need to reload the
> entire page for
> everything. A few suggestions here:
> 1. Almost all the buttons in all the pages are completely left aligned,
> which puts them farther left than the forms that contain the input fields
> themselves, its a good UX
> design if it could be put just under the fields, that is at the center of
> the page.
> 2. And the size of the buttons are completely dependent on the text it
> contains, again maintaining a common size for all buttons, except for really
> long text ones is a good
> practice, gives a good feel.
> 3. In the My account page, the first thing is Account Name, I think it is
> User Name. There might be some technical reason for the change there, but I
> feel it is a good
> thing to maintain a single naming convention throughout the site.
> 4. When browsing through the group list, the entire page is refreshed, it
> could be made to load dynamically through AJAX.
> 5. In a overall feel, the site seemed to be very rigid in UI, there could be
> some fluidity.
> I didn't go through the entire site, I might come up more suggestions as a
> browse through the pages, most of the above are very trivial things. I think
> this feed back would
> be helpful for the team to improve things.
>
> Thank you for the work done, and wish you for continual work.
>
Here's the fas code if you have a moment to implement the changes proposed
above:
http://git.fedorahosted.org/git/?p=fas.git
Hopefully we can thank you for your continued work :) It's a great way to
get involved if you're interested.
-Mike_______________________________________________
infrastructure mailing list
[email protected]
https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/infrastructure