The following is a response by Rev. Narelle Penman to the question about distributing the RA's survey? forms.
I have included it with permission.
 
Allan

 
In response to Alan's question about what to do with the form.
 
I am against handing it out - although I know it will get out via some in the parish who are signed up members of the Alliance.
 
My concerns:
 
This information will be in the hands of those with a vested interest to distort the results.  Already members of this group have put out a letter in this parish indicating that following the discussion paper in 1996 and prior to 1997 Assembly 80% of the church was against homosexuals in leadership, 85% of elders groups, etc. When in fact the figures related to the 8,000 people who responded to a survey - mainly those with a gripe.  Those who are not phased do not respond.  Considering there was 10-15 times more people involved in the study/discussion groups the 6,500 who responded negatively actually represented less than 10% of the church who took part in discussion -  and less than 1% of the church as a whole - not 80%.
 
This is not a survey by the church for the leadership or councils to base further discussion/proposals.  It is by a group trying to override existing structures, where everyone has a fair chance of putting forward issues in a balanced way.  Trying to hijack the agenda of the church. 
 
Because it is not an offical survey of the church and there is no compulsion for everyone to respond, it is left wide open for misuse, etc. etc. 
 
Members from this parish who have signed up to the alliance have decided to stop attending church at the moment, but are meeting as a home group, with the idea that they are going to be able to reform the church and bring about the required change with them in leadership of the church or have the grounds on which to mount a high court challenge to the church and bring about a split including leaving with assets.  This is political nonsense.
 
I do not intend allowing this group to hijack the agenda of this parish.  There are too many more important tasks on our agenda.  I will be discussing with the elders and see if they want to put out any statement on this matter/
 
Narelle
 

Reply via email to