It probably wasn't mentioned because it's got a bad reputation as being slow. 
It's easy to abuse it and end up with crappy performance. As long as you limit 
the amount of painting you do and how often you do it, I don't think using it 
is really an issue in practice.

From: Interest <> on behalf 
of Oleg Evseev <>
Sent: Wednesday, 12 October 2016 1:48:54 PM
To: Qt Project
Subject: Re: [Interest] [Quick Controls 2] Best way to add binding arrow tip to 

Great thanks, Shawn.

Canvas is what I searching for!

Even in canvas example there is a Talk bubble example that is look similar to 
tipped Popup!
[Встроенное изображение 1]

Canvas is Qt Quick Item, so it is quite easy to add it on the scene and add a 
shadows (or other effects) to it
[Встроенное изображение 2]
and use it as background for Qt Quick Controls.

Only thing that I miss is the inner border in Canvas (to be identical to 
Rectangle drawing principle). But for simple tipped popup (rectangle with 
rounded corners and tip) it was quite easy to recalculate coordinates points.
Plus, apparently there is the other solution with globalCompositeOperation for complex shapes (didn't test it).

I made tipped rectangle with Canvas and it looks great!

I really surprised, why using Canvas item was not suggested in first place?!

And you, Shawn, write this:

... we've always needed support for arbitrary shapes in QtQuick.  We’ll have 
them eventually…

like Canvas is not the really good solution - just a workaround. That is, it 
not claims to be "support for arbitrary shapes in QtQuick".

Why? How your ideal support for arbitrary shapes in QtQuick will look like in 
general words, then?

What about Canvas vs QSGGeometry Node approach? Only performance aspects?

Regards, Oleg.

2016-10-10 10:41 GMT+03:00 Shawn Rutledge 
You can add two rotated rectangles, one underneath for the border, and one (on 
top) for the fill, to cover up the edge of the main rectangle.  Next you will 
want a drop shadow, then you need a couple more Rectangles (or something from 
GraphicalEffects) underneath.

This is a good illustration of why we've always needed support for arbitrary 
shapes in QtQuick.  We’ll have them eventually…

Meanwhile you can use Canvas (draw the shape) or BorderImage (pull edge, corner 
and center pieces from an image and assemble them into a resizable balloon).

Interest mailing list<>
Interest mailing list

Reply via email to