On Thu, Jul 18, 2024, at 12:11, Oliver Nybroe wrote: > Thanks for sharing previous discussions, I will definitely take a look at > those before writing up the RFC. > > > > If you do with to go with an RFC, I'd like to see if your proposal > addresses whether this syntax should implicitly call > `parent::__construct()`, and if a semi colon is expected or not > (`public function __construct(public int $foo);` vs `public function > __construct(public int $foo)`). > Thank you, these are very valuable points to address in the RFC. > > I can definitely feel that there will be some mixed opinions about semicolon > vs no semi colon. > > > Best regards > Oliver Nybroe (he/him)
Don't forget to bottom post :) I have a feeling a semi-colon is going to be required to disambiguate: public function __construct(protected string $foo) protected string $bar; Without semi-colons, that is perfectly valid and confusing. — Rob
